We had a gathering of old gamers last weekend, and even completed some games between the beers:
Brittania - (the Romans (played by me) did their worst ever invasion of Britain - everybody managed to kill off some Roman Elites - never recovered after that)
1870 - Railroads along the Mississippi. Building railroads, buying and selling stocks, dealing, buying trains - I still don't understand how this can be funny, but we've been playing it for 15 years against each others and it is still amazing.
Puerto Rico - Got soundly beaten due to bad tactics, but it is still a great game.
Pitch Car - for the time in the evening when we are not able to understand the rules of any other game.
JM