william.stoppel
Elder Member
Spanish Civil WarSCW ?
Spanish Civil WarSCW ?
No-one else seems to have addressed this, so ....This is interesting, because I've only recently discovered that GWASL even exists !
Is there a part of this forum devoted to it ? Particularly interested in the Alpine War, which I see has a "module"...but the rules!?
Make up your own mind after gathering all the facts. Even Mark will agree on Desperation Morale that Guerra Civil, Genesis 48 and Dien Bien Phu were good, playtested products. They were only hamstrung by their horrid variant counter art and the quality of the counters. This was fixed in future editions. There are some excellent Critical Hit products out there. You just need to look and separate valid comments vice the “all CH products suck”.Wow, big thanks for the heads up "bprobst", much appreciated.....
I will not be purchasing any of their products...
Those reviews were damning.
This!Make up your own mind after gathering all the facts. Even Mark will agree on Desperation Morale that Guerra Civil, Genesis 48 and Dien Bien Phu were good, playtested products. They were only hamstrung by their horrid variant counter art and the quality of the counters. This was fixed in future editions. There are some excellent Critical Hit products out there. You just need to look and separate valid comments vice the “all CH products suck”.
Too bad you took the word of a CH hater!Wow, big thanks for the heads up "bprobst", much appreciated.....
I will not be purchasing any of their products...
Those reviews were damning.
I have no idea what these games are like, and, as stated, they are expensive...however, a member of this forum has very kindly agreed to sell me some CH GWASL stuff at an incredibly low price, so - we shall see ..Too bad you took the word of a CH hater!
As an absolute fan of CH, you can freely expose here the good reasons to purchase that product.Too bad you took the word of a CH hater!
Different context, but I always think Shaped Charge Weapon when I see SCW. One is in the ASL Index, one is not.....Spanish Civil War
Well. There can be a reason for ASL being expensive in general .. and CH GWASL being at an "incredibly low price".I have no idea what these games are like, and, as stated, they are expensive...however, a member of this forum has very kindly agreed to sell me some CH GWASL stuff at an incredibly low price, so - we shall see ..
My main interest will always be ASL.
I remember the same thing.I think that is what he is saying. I seem to recall having read something to this effect somewhere around here in this forum.
von Marwitz
I would have no problem if Guerra Civil became the official SCW gamette, much like Soldiers of the Negus will shortly be the Ethiopian one.I remember the same thing.
I have, and like Guerra Civil, but an official module would be great.
As a general rule of thumb that is the best course to take. Anything CH peddles is suspect at best.Wow, big thanks for the heads up "bprobst", much appreciated.....
I will not be purchasing any of their products...
Those reviews were damning.
Think RT would release the copyrights?I would have no problem if Guerra Civil became the official SCW gamette, much like Soldiers of the Negus will shortly be the Ethiopian one.
YupThink RT would release the copyrights?
How many R's in "Fat Chance"?
Pitcavage's comments are never "all CH products suck", except perhaps those released in the last 10 years or so, because, well, they all suck (or, at best are obscenely expensive for what you get). Mark's overview of the GWASL products confine themselves to those products. His reviews of the earlier CH products that generally don't suck are pretty fair too. I disagree with Pitcavage on many things but it's only rarely that I would consider his product descriptions to be unfair, and even a lot of those boil down to "my tastes differ from his". Desperation Morale is "only" a data point in the overview of any ASL product, but it's a pretty solid one.Make up your own mind after gathering all the facts.
Hey I just said I would have no problem with it, I didn't say the chances were good.Think RT would release the copyrights?
How many R's in "Fat Chance"?
- Far from solid. Only one haters opinion.Pitcavage's comments are never "all CH products suck", - Only 99% of them. He is a CH hater from day one.
except perhaps those released in the last 10 years or so, because, well, they all suck - And how would you know that? Oh, you read his site!
(or, at best are obscenely expensive for what you get). - Another lie. All packs start out at a low price and you can also get 30% off of that low price. After the items ship then the price goes up to normal but you can still get 30% off of that price. So, your a lier.
Mark's overview of the GWASL products confine themselves to those products. - But he never played any of them. He was on here begging people so send him pictures of the stuff. So his opinion means little to nothing.
His reviews of the earlier CH products that generally don't suck are pretty fair too. I disagree with Pitcavage on many things but it's only rarely that I would consider his product descriptions to be unfair, - Like i said, you just go by what he writes.
and even a lot of those boil down to "my tastes differ from his". Desperation Morale is "only" a data point in the overview of any ASL product, but it's a pretty solid one.
Having both iterations of the CH one and the PT of the new one I would go with the OT one to ge honestI would have no problem if Guerra Civil became the official SCW gamette, much like Soldiers of the Negus will shortly be the Ethiopian one.