‘Best’ large scenario?

[thedrake]

ABtF1 The Prize
66 The Bushmasters.

 

[pj norton]

CtR 17 "Clearing the Badlands"

The most fun monster scenario Ive ever played. The American player must play very aggressively and plan 2-3 turns in advance to have a shot. Several very different VCs must all be achieved. Uses the entire CtR map. Played it as each side, and enjoyed both sides immensely.

Yeah! This one is on my list of monsters to play someday.

 

[Polar Bear Vortex]

Road to Kozani Pass

 

[phlegm027]

Yep. BFP29 Hueishan Docks. Awesome scenario, Bob.

Some others with long double-digit playtimes for me:

BFP83 Second Belt. Excellent Kursk scenario.
BFP71 Surabaya Slugfest. Lots of fun.
VOTG12 Siberian Shockwave. Stalking

I’m so

 

[phlegm027]

Rommel at the Meuse Or Finale: Onhaye

I’m so

 

[phlegm027]

No such thing as a good small scenario, I say.

 

['Ol Fezziwig]

As an addenda to my previous post, the two large scenarios in the To the Bridge! AP were a freakin' blast!

 

[rtroha]

U23 Rehearsal for Crete was like playing three scenarios simultaneously. Just played AP56 Quagmire a few weeks ago and that also had three separate battles going on across the playing area.

 

[Eagle4ty]

U23 Rehearsal for Crete was like playing three scenarios simultaneously. Just played AP56 Quagmire a few weeks ago and that also had three separate battles going on across the playing area.

Not to mention it has "old geezer" appeal being one of the SL series games redone for ASL.

 

[rdw5150]

Somewhere recently online someone was talking about one that hasn't been mentioned here: 117 Maggot Hill

I love this scenario. Played it twice, winning and the Japanese and losing as the American. I bought a 3D Jeff DeYoung board of the map. Need to haul that to ASLOK some year and troll for an opponent.

Peace

Roger

 

[rdw5150]

Yep. BFP29 Hueishan Docks. Awesome scenario, Bob.

Some others with long double-digit playtimes for me:

BFP83 Second Belt. Excellent Kursk scenario.
BFP71 Surabaya Slugfest. Lots of fun.
VOTG12 Siberian Shockwave. Stalingrad

I've played all of these (can you tell my buddy and I like large scenarios). All were real fun.

Peace

Roger

 

[burniefox]

I've played all of these (can you tell my buddy and I like large scenarios). All were real fun.

Peace

Roger

BFP29 and BFP83 are modern classics, IMHO.

 

[Honza]

CtR 17 "Clearing the Badlands"

The most fun monster scenario Ive ever played. The American player must play very aggressively and plan 2-3 turns in advance to have a shot. Several very different VCs must all be achieved. Uses the entire CtR map. Played it as each side, and enjoyed both sides immensely.

Glad to hear that. It looks great on paper.....

 

[Vic Provost]

From the new Journal #13, there is J209 Corking the Chambois Bottle, from Ron Duenskie who playtests for me and is, along with Paul Sidhu and Steve Pleva, amongst the best players up here in the Northeast USA. These guys have all beaten on me in the past and are truly in the upper level of players I have seen in action in my lifetime, this scenario looks like a ton of fun as the Germans on attack try to pierce an American screen to get at the Poles and the VCs beyond. Well worth taking a look at, I will sometime this year.

 

[M Faulkner]

The Eternal City SP33

 

[Smedley]

From the new Journal #13, there is J209 Corking the Chambois Bottle, from Ron Duenskie who playtests for me and is, along with Paul Sidhu and Steve Pleva, amongst the best players up here in the Northeast USA. These guys have all beaten on me in the past and are truly in the upper level of players I have seen in action in my lifetime, this scenario looks like a ton of fun as the Germans on attack try to pierce an American screen to get at the Poles and the VCs beyond. Well worth taking a look at, I will sometime this year.

Hey Vic,

I will be playing this Thursday at Nor'easter as part of a team game with Jim Povey, Mike Sprague and Paul Anderson.......... Stop by and have a peek.

Rob

 

[Honza]

The Eternal City SP33

The battle for Rome?

 

[M Faulkner]

The battle for Rome?

Yes, by the 1st Special Service Force.

 

[Honza]

Yes, by the 1st Special Service Force.

The one in Hollow Legions is Germans vs Italians. So this is later on? Americans vs Germans?

 

[M Faulkner]

The one in Hollow Legions is Germans vs Italians. So this is later on? Americans vs Germans?

Yes. American vs German June, 4, 1944.