Then just say "treat them as C". It leads to confusion...as that is assuming what it meant...as leaders can exempt SOME units that are subject to 5.4
its not Clear.
This (treat them as Conscripts) is different. 1st Liners ELR to Conscripts. Conscripts Disrupt.
I, for one, did not see any confusion. Your question (do leaders prevent the penalties) was a good and
reasonable one. IMHO, the rules are crystal clear as written.
I find MMP's writing is a lot like mathematical writing in the following sense: IMHO, if MMP words something
in a particular way, there is a reason they did so. If the wording were different, something would change. I
find it a good exercise (in ASL and maths) to ask myself "Why this particular wording? What would change?"
It helped me focus on what the rules actually say and mean versus what I
think the rules say or mean. Here's one for
you: I saw an SSR for an MMP scenario that said "Randomly select..." and not "choose via Random Selection."
I would say it's an easy one, only because I know the answer, and we all know that "it can easily be shown..."
is mathematical double talk for "I happen to know how to do it."
Good hunting!
indy
