Red Barricades irrelevant moon meaning

[bigdirt32]

Does this mean no moon for a -2 modifier to NVR or mean no modifier to the NVR.

 

[CTKnudsen]

Yes, not sure why that is in there, if you are going by E1.11 you'd think that overcast weather would create overcast clouds automatically, but that you'd still use the moon phases (from the CG Roster) to figure out the starting NVR.

 

[bigdirt32]

I would agree but disagree, I am trying to find out what exactly the meaning of irrelevant is meaning. Not sure you can use the moon phase if it says overcast makes it irrelevant. So really the question is do you use the no moon modifier or is there no modifier.

 

[Eagle4ty]

I would agree but disagree, I am trying to find out what exactly the meaning of irrelevant is meaning. Not sure you can use the moon phase if it says overcast makes it irrelevant. So really the question is do you use the no moon modifier or is there no modifier.

The Overcast is there for Starting of Rain/Snow, use the regular Ch E Moon Phase and Cloud cover to determine NVR/NVR-Change.

 

[bigdirt32]

This is the wording I am pertaining to: 11.6234 RUSSIAN NIGHT ASSAULT: If a "Russian Assault" CG scenario has been generated, the Russian may declare it to be a Night scenario (E1) [EXC: maximum of 4 in RO CG III]. In such a scenario, the Russians are always the Scenario Attacker and the Germans always the Scenario Defender, despite both sides setting up on-/off-map. As the Scenario Attacker, the Russians may use Cloaking for their on map as well as off-map units. The total number of Cloaking counters remains one per squad-equivalent (E1.411) in the Russian at-start OB. Reinforcements entering from off-map always have Freedom of Movement (E1.21). Determine the Cloud Cover and initial Base NVR as per E1.11 [EXC: use the historical Moon Phase listing on the Moon column of the CG Roster]. Note that a result of Overcast on the NVR table does not invoke E3.5; Overcast weather does invoke E3.5, and also makes the Cloud Cover Overcast and the Moon Phase irrelevant.

So what modifier is used if Moon phase is irrelevant?

 

[bigdirt32]

So I guess this one stumps everyone then too?

 

[Sparafucil3]

So I guess this one stumps everyone then too?

Doesn't stump me. I don't play CG's -- jim

 

[BattleSchool]

I don't play CG's -- jim

Just as well...

Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance.

 

[Sparafucil3]

Just as well...

Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance. Read ASOP... Assault Move. Read ASOP... Advance.

Close. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move.

Final Fire.

Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance.

-- jim

 

[von Marwitz]

Close. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move. Read ASOP. Assault move. Read ASOP. Assault Move.

Final Fire.

Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance. Read ASOP. Advance.

-- jim

Sounds like a fun game! Gotta love to Advance through the ASOP.

von Marwitz

 

[apbills]

This is the wording I am pertaining to: 11.6234 RUSSIAN NIGHT ASSAULT: If a "Russian Assault" CG scenario has been generated, the Russian may declare it to be a Night scenario (E1) [EXC: maximum of 4 in RO CG III]. In such a scenario, the Russians are always the Scenario Attacker and the Germans always the Scenario Defender, despite both sides setting up on-/off-map. As the Scenario Attacker, the Russians may use Cloaking for their on map as well as off-map units. The total number of Cloaking counters remains one per squad-equivalent (E1.411) in the Russian at-start OB. Reinforcements entering from off-map always have Freedom of Movement (E1.21). Determine the Cloud Cover and initial Base NVR as per E1.11 [EXC: use the historical Moon Phase listing on the Moon column of the CG Roster]. Note that a result of Overcast on the NVR table does not invoke E3.5; Overcast weather does invoke E3.5, and also makes the Cloud Cover Overcast and the Moon Phase irrelevant.

So what modifier is used if Moon phase is irrelevant?

It means they goofed. You still need to use the Moon Phase, The Roll on the table is irrelevant, you cross reference the "Overcast" row with the moon phase to determine the NVR.