Westy
Member
Just got back from Kokoda track - 8 day trek. Amazing experience and simply incredible terrain. Have enough material for at least 20 scenarios. Curious as to what level of interest there might be.
Kokoda Trip
- Thread starter Westy
- Start date
von Marwitz
Forum Guru
Vic Provost
Forum Guru
- Joined
- Sep 18, 2016
- Messages
- 1,627
- Reaction score
- 3,744
- Location
- Pittsfield, MA USA
- First name
- Vic
- Country
-
Me too, bring it on, I want to get a Kokoda Trail series of scenarios into Dispatches, just published the first one but was not sure what to look at next there, if you come up with some and have no other outlet, please contact me at aslbunker@aol.com I am VERY Interested! Vic.
Steve H
Senior Member
More PTO is always welcome!
VonHutier
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jun 6, 2021
- Messages
- 708
- Reaction score
- 519
- Country
-
My thoughts exactly
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2003
- Messages
- 19,910
- Reaction score
- 5,956
- Location
- St-Légier
- First name
- Robin
- Country
-
Kokoda is a very interesting campaign.
I day go for it.
I day go for it.
Eagle4ty
Forum Guru
The entire Kokoda, Gona-Buna Campaign is quite interesting and very underrepresented both historically and in ASL. Taken in total it lasted longer and began earlier than the Guadalcanal operation as well as incorporating a greater number of combatants from all sides involved along with the resultant greater degree of casualties involved. The number of Battle casualties (KIA, WIA & MIA) by suffered by the Australians and Americans was three times greater than those suffered by the Marines and US Army units on The Canal. By comparison, the USMC units on Guadalcanal suffered approximately one battle casualty for every 34 men whereas the in the Kokoda, Gona-Buna Operation the ratio was one out of every 11 men committed, the majority being suffered among the Australians at about a 3:2 ratio. This may be because of the general strategic/operational nature of the struggles; the Australians and Americans at Kokoda, Gona-Buna were generally conducting an offensive operation whereas the marines on the canal were generally in a defensive posture. Of course, if one takes into account the non-battle casualties form Malaria, dysentery, jungle-rot, etc., the ratios were quite similar. One Australian company was able to muster only a single soldier as declared battle worthy after the fight for Gona, and he had a temperature of 101 degrees and wasn't suffering from a malaria bout at the time. My dad's company fared a bit better after Buna, being able to muster three battle worthy men (my dad wasn't one of them).
Just about finished "The Battle of Kokada Plateau" by David W. Cameron. It deals with the early battles on the Kokoda Track soon after the Japanese landings. The book has a lot of details, lots of first-person accounts and the early clashes for Kokoda village are described in details, sometime down to platoon/section level for both sides. You really get a feel for how terrible the conditions and the terrain was. I recommend it if you are looking to design a scenario featuring the early clashes.
Tuomo
Keeper of the Funk
DASL PTO?
Thunderchief
Elder Member
Those Ragged Bloody Heroes (Gona HASL) was released in the 1990s via Critical Hit, but it has not had much love (as far as ROAR is concerned anyway).
Those Ragged Bloody Heroes / New Guinea I
Those Ragged Bloody Heroes (TRBH), like the book of the same name, depicts the 7th Australian Division’s frustrating attempts to take the village of Gona on New Guinea in late 1942 (their Ame…
www.desperationmorale.com
Craig Benn
Senior Member
Was there a greater number of combatants for Kokoda and Buna than Guadalcanal?
Off the top of my head - and without researching it;
Guadalcanal
1st US Marine division
2nd US Marine division
25th Infantry division
Americal infantry division
An independent infantry regiment - 148th?
Japanese 2nd & 38th infantry divisions
Kawaguchi Brigade
Various SNLF
Kokoda /Buna
7th Australian division
Militia Brigade
32nd US infantry division
Regiment from 41st division
South Seas detachment reinforced by various bits and pieces (about division strength)
Take the above with a pinch of salt...
I'm always happy to see new PTO scenarios. There does seem to be a disproportionate amount of USMC scenarios vs US Army/Aussies in SW Pacific theatre. I'd even go as far to say there are plenty of Burma scenarios now.
The really unrepresented theatre in terms of forces committed/duration is Italy imo. But wandering off topic...
Off the top of my head - and without researching it;
Guadalcanal
1st US Marine division
2nd US Marine division
25th Infantry division
Americal infantry division
An independent infantry regiment - 148th?
Japanese 2nd & 38th infantry divisions
Kawaguchi Brigade
Various SNLF
Kokoda /Buna
7th Australian division
Militia Brigade
32nd US infantry division
Regiment from 41st division
South Seas detachment reinforced by various bits and pieces (about division strength)
Take the above with a pinch of salt...
I'm always happy to see new PTO scenarios. There does seem to be a disproportionate amount of USMC scenarios vs US Army/Aussies in SW Pacific theatre. I'd even go as far to say there are plenty of Burma scenarios now.
The really unrepresented theatre in terms of forces committed/duration is Italy imo. But wandering off topic...
Westy
Member
Hi folks. Will download some images from the trek. I went with 7 other family members and it was just incredible. Most notable was how incredibly mentally taxing it was. Of the 8 days, it pissed down non-stop for 4. Going downcliff (hill doesn’t do it justice) was unbelievably treacherous. And the fuzzy wuzzies were nothing short of superheroes.
Westy
Member
Me holding the 39th Battalion Flag…..I had the honour of carrying the flag
Westy
Member
Hi Joe, The trek has inspired me to read heaps of books and unit histories on the topic. And I took lots of photos of the terrain. I simply can believe the Japanese attacked up Mission ridge. It would be a quadruple ridge line…..at least!
Westy
Member
I will. Let me know if anyone is interested in playtesting.
Westy
Member
Thanks Vic….will get into it soon. What surprised me is the number of Aussie counter-attack situations when the aussies at a strategic level were conducting a delaying action.
Westy
Member
Give us pictures or it didn't happen...
von Marwitz
