J226 Drawing the Kroh

Tuomo

Keeper of the Funk
Joined
Feb 10, 2003
Messages
4,654
Reaction score
5,540
Location
Rock Bottom
Country
llUnited States
Played this Crete paradrop against Jeremy Busby for the ASL League.

Situation: Crete. 10 FJ squad-equivalents (with 9-2 and dm 81mm MTR) drop onto boards 58 and 73 (augmented by several overlays - take my advice and use the draggable overlay VASL extension to set this up). They are bolstered by 10 ML8 squads coming in from the east edge (top edge of the pics below) - the reinforcements also get a dm 81mm MTR, just in case the paras forgot theirs. They have 7 turns to clear 10 Aussie squads off the Level 2+ hexes on the northern (left) half of the hill on board 58. The Aussies are enjoying three captured Italian ART guns, and with SSR 2 explaining just who gets Captured Use, Non-Qualified Use, and Ammo Shortage, believe me, you're going to want to go to Texas ASL and download the Player Aid that explains just what the B and X numbers are.

The pic below shows the situation after the German para scatter on turn 1. Wings A and C hit their drop points; Wing A had the 81mm MTR (hoping they could start lobbing shells at the Aussies from their side of the hill) and Wing C had the 9-2 (because I figured we'd need him on that side of the hill). Wing B missed his initial drop point (73P4) and dropped instead on 58C5, not terrible but not great either. Two squads from Wing A drifted right over the Aussie defense and got shot up; the rest of the folks did as well as one can expect - note that Orchards are Olive Groves and Grain is Vineyards, both of which cause MCs when paras land there.
25968

The first few turns featured the usual silliness as the paras ran around trying to rally and rearm (which they were singularly bad at) and the German reinforcements opted for a "surround the hill strategy". Here's the situation at the end of German turn 3. Note the Melee in 58P2; Jeremy was generally happy to sit in his foxholes and shoot me up, but he saw a nice opportunity to grab some of the para's gear, so his 9-1 and 228/MMG came over and grabbed a loot box, scoring an LMG. The unopened loot box in P1 is the para's 81mm MTR; I never did get to it, and that sucked. Plus, that 9-1 and MMG crew were a royal PITA, repulsing several German squads as they tried to get past.

25969

As the game wore on, my "encircle the hill" strategy sure did result in the hill being encircled, but it also turned into a lot of situations that had an alarming sameness: I'd advance up adjacent to an Aussie unit in a Foxhole, he'd fire and break me, and that was that. The 458/LMG in Y7 was particularly good at this. Meanwhile, the reinforcing 81mm MTR (which luckily came in on turn 2) had a choice to make - take a little longer to move up to Level 3 and get into the LOS of the assumed Aussie Guns on Level 3, or just get into the game earlier by settling for firing on the eastern crestline positions where the Aussie squads were. He chose.... poorly.... taking the former route and essentially being useless until turn 5. In his defense, he did break an MMG crew and leader in U4, but he'd have been far more useful just sitting in N10 or BB8 and prosecuting those sides of the hill. Lesson learned.

At the end, the MTR in L4 got a ridiculously lucky Smoke hit on the concealed stack in Y5, which allowed the Germans a chance to get up the hill, but the Pinned squad/LMG in BB4 broke the (battle-hardened) 10-2 and 238 as they rushed the hill in Z3, and the Italian 75ART nailed my 8-1 and two MMC's with an Intensive Fire shot as they zoomed into Q4. Ultimately, just not enough unbroken Germans around to make things happen.
25970

If I had to do it again (and I'd like to - it's a fun scenario and Jeremy is a good and pleasurable opponent to spend time with), I'd maybe try to concentrate the reinforcements a bit more instead of surrounding the hill. I had too many 1-on-1 adjacent opportunities where I just didn't survive the Aussie prep fire; if I'd have given them more targets to shoot at, I think we could have cracked the hill a little easier. And sure, the Aussies could have reinforced from wherever I wasn't attacking, but they needed to get out of their foxholes and wouldn't have new foxholes to move into.

The other thing to note - once the close-in brawl starts, LOS is pretty open, and defensive fire opportunities are definitely there. So while the German attack takes a while to get organized and make progress, there's a lot of bullets in the air on the last few turns, and the Germans can definitely make up for lost time.

Definitely worth playing!
 
Last edited:

Tuomo

Keeper of the Funk
Joined
Feb 10, 2003
Messages
4,654
Reaction score
5,540
Location
Rock Bottom
Country
llUnited States
Oh, and for grins, here's how we played SSR2:

B11 Guns:
  • Become circled B10 due to the Ammo Shortage (A19.131)
  • Manned by a 127, Ammo Shortage + Captured = B9, X11, Low Ammo 10, ROF -1
  • Manned by anybody else, above + non-qualified = B7, X11, Low Ammo 10 , ROF -2
  • Intensive Fire does its normal thing, lowering the B# by 2
  • Captured Use means Red TH #s
SW:
  • All become B11 due to Ammo Shortage (A19.131)
  • MMGs manned by a 228 or SMC, Ammo Shortage = B11, X12
  • MMGs manned by anybody else, Ammo Shortage + Captured = B9, X12, ROF-1
  • Sustained Fire does its normal thing, lowering the B# by 2
  • No Firelanes due to Ammo Shortage
Low Ammo: change the original B# to an X#, creates a new B# one less than the original B#

I have to say, this is a bit much.
 

VonHutier

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2021
Messages
631
Reaction score
472
Country
llUnited Kingdom
Got your #14 Journal then ? Hoping to receive mine this week from 2nd Chance Games ( UK ).
Looks a great scenario, look forward to playing it !
 

Andrew Rogers

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2010
Messages
149
Reaction score
421
Location
Canberra, Australia
First name
Andy
Country
llAustralia
Mr Tuomo. Glad you had fun playing a parachute drop scenario. These are tough to balance given the inherent variability in these designs. As to the rules with regards to the Guns and SW, "yes" it is tedious. Sometimes capturing the history of the engagement can make it problematic from a rules complexity perspective. We had captured Italian guns, low ammo and selectively trained men!
 

Doug Leslie

Elder Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2017
Messages
1,639
Reaction score
1,587
Location
Scotland
Country
llUnited Kingdom
Paradrop scenarios can be great fun, but they are a brave choice in a tournament: the landings are just a bit too random. Definitely sounds like a good scenario to give a go to in a "friendly" game though. Just ordered Journal 14 this evening, so will be looking at this one with interest!
 

Michael R

Minor Hero
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Feb 4, 2003
Messages
4,658
Reaction score
4,204
Location
La Belle Province
First name
Michael
Country
llCanada
Paradrop scenarios can be great fun, but they are a brave choice in a tournament: the landings are just a bit too random. Definitely sounds like a good scenario to give a go to in a "friendly" game though. Just ordered Journal 14 this evening, so will be looking at this one with interest!
I agree so much. I can't believe it when I see a paratroop drop scenario in a tournament. I wouldn't choose it because I want to decrease the luck aspect of a round in a tournament.
 

Vic Provost

Forum Guru
Joined
Sep 18, 2016
Messages
1,512
Reaction score
3,431
Location
Pittsfield, MA USA
First name
Vic
Country
llUnited States
I agree so much. I can't believe it when I see a paratroop drop scenario in a tournament. I wouldn't choose it because I want to decrease the luck aspect of a round in a tournament.
Right On Mike, that is crazy having them in a tourney unless there is a round full of them as a theme. Paradrops are fun but very frustrating in my experience, they almost never land where you want and especially where you need them. Scattered is the word I would use for all but a few that I have played. I would much rather come down in a glider, as long as enemy AA is not a big problem.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2006
Messages
224
Reaction score
152
Location
Paris area
Country
llFrance
J226 SSR2 says: "Australians treat foxholes as woods for Rout..."
Unclear for me: what happens if the nearest 1S foxhole is already occupied by a MMC? Can the broken unit ignored it and rout elsewhere?
Same SSR2 about foxholes for Rally: does the broken unit have to be IN the foxhole? I guess yes, but it seems unclear.

About the Italians guns: ammo shortage do not apply to Captured Guns/SW (A21.11).
 
Last edited:

Perry

Forum Guru
Joined
Feb 4, 2003
Messages
1,811
Reaction score
2,770
Location
Baltimore, MD
Country
llUnited States
J226 SSR2 says: "Australians treat foxholes as woods for Rout..."
Unclear for me: what happens if the nearest 1S foxhole is already occupied by a MMC? Can the broken unit ignored it and rout elsewhere?
Same SSR2 about foxholes for Rally: does the broken unit have to be IN the foxhole? I guess yes, but it seems unclear.

About the Italians guns: ammo shortage do not apply to Captured Guns/SW (A21.11).
This isn’t the best place to raise these issues, but I didn’t want to leave them unresolved.

Ammunition Shortage does apply to the Australian Captured Guns. The SSR is clear, as Captured Guns are the only Australian Guns.

Treatment of foxholes for Australian rout/rally purposes are unaffected by whether they occupied or not.
 

VonHutier

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2021
Messages
631
Reaction score
472
Country
llUnited Kingdom
Foxholes can't be overstacked. What Perry is saying is that the foxhole location is a rout location in this scenario. The routing unit doesn't enter the foxhole if it is already occupied.
Thank you for that very quick clarification..!
 

ScottRomanowski

Forum Guru
Joined
Jul 31, 2010
Messages
1,642
Reaction score
2,120
Location
Massachusetts
Country
llUnited States
Foxholes can't be overstacked. What Perry is saying is that the foxhole location is a rout location in this scenario. The routing unit doesn't enter the foxhole if it is already occupied.
That means that a unit might be forced to rout to a foxhole that it can't enter, which may make for some strange routing situations. I guess you'll have to think about rout paths carefully here.
 

Michael R

Minor Hero
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Feb 4, 2003
Messages
4,658
Reaction score
4,204
Location
La Belle Province
First name
Michael
Country
llCanada
Foxholes can't be overstacked. What Perry is saying is that the foxhole location is a rout location in this scenario. The routing unit doesn't enter the foxhole if it is already occupied.
Funny, I read it the other way. Since he states the foxholes are rout/rally terrain regardless of occupation, that implies to me the hex with a foxhole is a rout/rally hex.
 

Doug Leslie

Elder Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2017
Messages
1,639
Reaction score
1,587
Location
Scotland
Country
llUnited Kingdom
Funny, I read it the other way. Since he states the foxholes are rout/rally terrain regardless of occupation, that implies to me the hex with a foxhole is a rout/rally hex.
I think that we are actually reading it the same way. My reading is that the routing unit doesn't have to enter the foxhole to qualify for rally benefits.
 
Top