'Seeing' what a unit can 'see'....

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
More insane weirdness. It's like Crazy-Planet at BF.

Let's copy the whole rug here...

Go Back Battlefront Forum > CMx2 > Combat Mission Red Thunder
Reload this Page Is there a button to reveal all units LOS ?
User Name Remember Me?
Password
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Today's Posts Search

Combat Mission Red Thunder Discussion board for Combat Mission Red Thunder

Reply
View First Unread View First Unread
Thread Tools
#1
Old Yesterday, 10:04 PM
Destraex1 Destraex1 is offline
Senior Member

Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 537
Default Is there a button to reveal all units LOS ?
I see in most battle tutorials and even chris's youtube videos. People are manually pressing and dragging a line all over the place to see what they can and cannot see.
Can I press space bar and just see different colours indicating where I can and cannot see on the map?
Reply With Quote
#2
Old Yesterday, 11:40 PM
ASL Veteran ASL Veteran is offline
Senior Member

Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Northern New Jersey
Posts: 2,817
Default
Quote:
Originally Posted by Destraex1 View Post
I see in most battle tutorials and even chris's youtube videos. People are manually pressing and dragging a line all over the place to see what they can and cannot see.
Can I press space bar and just see different colours indicating where I can and cannot see on the map?
No there isn't a way to do that
__________________
It ain't what you don't know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so.
Reply With Quote
#3
Old Today, 12:01 AM
Destraex1 Destraex1 is offline
Senior Member

Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 537
Default
I guess it takes a keen eye then. Shame the terrain is not so easy to distinguish.
Reply With Quote
#4
Old Today, 12:03 AM
Battlefront.com Battlefront.com is offline
Administrator

Join Date: Feb 1999
Posts: 18,831
Default
This has been requested of CM since 1999. It will never, ever, ever be a feature in the game. Ever. Players have too much precise information at their fingertips without working hard for it. If one wants absolutely ridiculously precise and exact information then we want them to work so hard at it that they get annoyed and stop. CM never has been, and never will be, a game tailored to those who feel that level of detail is required to play.

Steve

P.S. Never, ever. Just in case you missed the first part
Reply With Quote
#5
Unread Today, 02:20 AM
Michael Emrys Michael Emrys is online now
Senior Member

Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Port Townsend, WA
Posts: 21,924
Default
Besides, how could you possibly code for that? Would the command reveal targets of x size as seen by a man prone, kneeling, standing, from the turret of a tank? How tall a tank? And then what about the targets that are not of x size, but y, z...Ω? Gets complicated, doesn't it?

Michael
__________________
Among those who have witnessed my all-knowing...er...knowledge and have stepped forward to embrace the Light, let these be known as the First Apostles: Bergerbitz, fytinghellfish, Andreas, noxnoctum, user38, DLaurier, wolf66, Yankee Dog. You too may join the elect. Just put your hands on the monitor and cry out from your heart, "I believe!"
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
I especially like the Sr. Citizen at the end making a shnook of himself. The OP asked "Can I press space bar and just see different colours indicating where I can and cannot see on the map?"

How that translated into Mr. Emry's knuckleheaded post remains a mystery.

Steve's stupid (yes, I said stupid) take on this whole issue just solidifies his break with understanding the game he is making. But since Emry backs him up, in that spectaculary wierd post, warms my heart that there is just craziness on both sides of the isle.

One can only wonder what goes on inside Charlies private world....
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
I would want, and I think many other people would want, is a general idea what a unit would possibly 'see' from an 'action spot'. Since the possibility is not concrete (look up what the word possibility means...), then we are just talking about a tool that facilitates players time. If we need an example, then we just need to look at the slow rate of play of the latest AAR (GO ELVIS!).

I suppose that Steve has become as boring and useless as a Bill Gates. Hopefully, he will step down and wander around the woods till he finds something else to do. Or gets eaten by a bear.
 

mOBIUS

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2008
Messages
650
Reaction score
4
Location
Kalifornia
Since they have action spots they could use those as reference points. Can the selected unit 'see' the ground of the action spot? If so the ground mesh would not be shaded. Everything else would. Seeing is only drawing a LOS ray, nothing to do with size of spot. The LOS tool doesn't ask for a size.

This would be a very time expensive process so would kill a RT game. I've wanted something like this in PCO but since it doesn't use Action spots I'm not sure how it could be implemented. In Civ 3D your units only see the land mesh that they have discovered. Everything else is invisible.
 
Last edited:

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
Since they have action spots they could use those as reference points. Can the selected unit 'see' the ground of the action spot? If so the ground mesh would not be shaded. Everything else would. Seeing is only drawing a LOS ray, nothing to do with size of spot. The LOS tool doesn't ask for a size.

This would be a very time expensive process so would kill a RT game. I've wanted something like this in PCO but since it doesn't use Action spots I'm not sure how it could be implemented. In Civ 3D your units only see the land mesh that they have discovered. Everything else is invisible.
I would be happy enough if it was just possible during the setup. But it is just ridiculous for Steve to say that the game needs to be 'hard' and makes some inane comment about 'level of detail'....I requote:

This has been requested of CM since 1999. It will never, ever, ever be a feature in the game. Ever. Players have too much precise information at their fingertips without working hard for it. If one wants absolutely ridiculously precise and exact information then we want them to work so hard at it that they get annoyed and stop. CM never has been, and never will be, a game tailored to those who feel that level of detail is required to play.

Steve

P.S. Never, ever. Just in case you missed the first part
It's just stupid. The game reeks of detail. The player knows every man's status and ammo load etc. And, of course, it is another example of how they belittle things that people want. Everyone should get the feeling by now that they don't want to do much more in the way of features. The UI and other annoyances are not getting features.

P.S. Just in case you missed it, it's stupid. Stupid is as Stupid does.
 

Redwolf

Member # 3665
Joined
Sep 2, 2002
Messages
5,113
Reaction score
39
Location
MA, USA
Country
llUnited States
I know that Charles doesn't communicate on the forum since it distracts from the coding.

It's been almost 7 years since the CMx2 release.

At this point I think it would be worthwhile to spend -say- 4 Charles months away from coding and instead having a deep look at where we ended up after we painted the floor.

There are a lot of computing resources, all of programming time, CPU time and GPU time, spent on random things that make no sense and pink elephants in the room get overlooked as far as changes are concerned. Not overlooked on the forums, but the fanbois really don't help. They think they do but they make it worse and consume resources. Steve seems to be in a state where he cannot transport specific technical issues to Charles, although Charles seems to pick up some things even after fanbois and Steve muddy it up, witness the MG fix.
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
I know that Charles doesn't communicate on the forum since it distracts from the coding.

It's been almost 7 years since the CMx2 release.

At this point I think it would be worthwhile to spend -say- 4 Charles months away from coding and instead having a deep look at where we ended up after we painted the floor.

There are a lot of computing resources, all of programming time, CPU time and GPU time, spent on random things that make no sense and pink elephants in the room get overlooked as far as changes are concerned. Not overlooked on the forums, but the fanbois really don't help. They think they do but they make it worse and consume resources. Steve seems to be in a state where he cannot transport specific technical issues to Charles, although Charles seems to pick up some things even after fanbois and Steve muddy it up, witness the MG fix.
Unfortunately, many times the answer is "What we need is a totally new program!". That is, they will decide that the present program does not use the state of the art hardware to its potential and they need to start anew (redo the same periods of warfare also...ahem). But, I found it odd that they were saying they will have some makeover on CMSF...in addition to a new modern battle product? It really seems the product management is not defined, to say the least.

I think they know they have a winner in CMRT as far as sales. They probably have a good handle on the bug situation as far as releasing this version of product (CM 3.0 is not great a break from CM 2.0 IMO). In other words, post release programming time might be freed up. Will that be used to spiffy up old release? Don't bet on it. Not if it don't come wit some dollars. Bet on CM 3.0 Upgrades first.

But I most concerned about the design philosophy and the outright knuckleheadedness shown by Steve. His vision of the product is too blurred by his loathing to put development time into anything he doesn't have to. His reasoning is suspect and even in the case when he knows something is worthwhile, like the comman-plan layer, he reasons it away with much too much programming time. Something as simple as improving an ambush command is on the back burner. Does anyone believe it would take "Charles-days" or even "Charles-Hours" to make this?

So, as the curve goes, we are seeing the CM product finding it's state of being. They will be more than happy to crank it till the handle falls off. And we will buy. At least for now.
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
This is an absolutely horrible justification for making a game feature. Customers are, often, totally wrong about what makes a game good and what features are needed to get the game to that point. Because if all it took was playing a game to know how to design one, don't you think you'd have better games to choose from than the ones you do?
I might have a new sig line....
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
I think it would be better if Steve just said "It's work we don't want to do". He is making a royal ass out of himself and demonstrating the lengths he will go through to 'prove' his point. Too bad he can't program. he could put his abundant energy into making something.
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
Wowza. I mean...WTF?

#29
Old Yesterday, 07:46 PM
Battlefront.com Battlefront.com is offline
Administrator

Join Date: Feb 1999
Posts: 18,858
Default
I just realized it's a zen thing. Some of our customers are only focused on choosing a path to get to a specific end destination. Others are much more interested in knowing the details of the path and to weigh the choices within against the choices in other paths. Others want to choose a path, enjoy their time on it, and don't really care where the wind up.

These are three totally different and largely incompatible ways of playing a game. That's because the game's very core, and soul, needs to be tailored to just one of these groups. We've chosen the latter.

Steve
There is no core or soul since the damn game is designed to play in two different modes! I mean, come-on, is this guy tripping or what???

It is isn't the customers, stupid, its the games design slips and product mismanagement and lack of vision as far as how to interact with a user-interface. It's simple stuff. Like a captive market. Very simple. People want this crap. I want this crap. But I can't stand to listen to your phony-baloney crock of sheet.
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
How demented is this?

Checking LOS from each waypoint is not necessary for playing successfully. Insisting that it is necessary is part of the problem. RealTime CM players don't need this info to win, which underscores my point quite nicely.
Huh. Who knew? Steve is a closet twitch-crowd guy after all. Not that there is anything wrong with that....
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
We have to strike a balance between these two extremes because there's no way we can give each what they want. Mostly because what they say they want is not what they actually want
Mein Kampf?
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
I suppose I could go on for awhile since Steve is a priceless target.

But, anyone can see through this senseless stance he has taken. It does him, and BF, no good. In fact, BF might even suggest he take a back seat at this point. Unless they feel the captive audience can sustain even more nonsense. There is a point at which decent people will voice concerns about a thing they have in common. And, that is, to like and look forward to. That is, to improve. The resistance is not only apparent...it is obnoxious and conceited.

This stupidity on Steve's part has to stop. It has no good purpose other than to be divisive. And he certainly is so blinded by his ego he can't see the forest for the trees.

I call on anyone in BF to have the courage to stop this flagrant attack on the forward development of this product.

No one?
 

mOBIUS

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2008
Messages
650
Reaction score
4
Location
Kalifornia
Wowza. I mean...WTF?
There is no core or soul since the damn game is designed to play in two different modes! I mean, come-on, is this guy tripping or what???
Neither fish nor fowl.
I at first thought I knew what the point of the thread was but as it continued - not so much.

I didn't know the game didn't have a LOS tool as it would be 'too much micro-management'. But there is a Target tool which not only finds the LOS from the current position but teleports into the future and finds the LOS from possible future positions. It is only one of an infinte number of future positions because things could change in the turn. Thus you not only can micro-manage the current universe you can micro-manage an infinite number of other universes.
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
I can't believe some of these utterances by Steve. RT and WEGO are the same? What?

It is like Texas Hold'em poker. You can play tournies, or you can play cash games. On the surface, they look the same. But anyone with experience can tell you, it is a completely different game.

The fact that Steve plays RT on a MAC is just frightening.
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
Neither fish nor fowl.
I at first thought I knew what the point of the thread was but as it continued - not so much.

I didn't know the game didn't have a LOS tool as it would be 'too much micro-management'. But there is a Target tool which not only finds the LOS from the current position but teleports into the future and finds the LOS from possible future positions. It is only one of an infinte number of future positions because things could change in the turn. Thus you not only can micro-manage the current universe you can micro-manage an infinite number of other universes.
But that's OK, because the coding has already been done. See? That is uber-gamey-info under the bridge. Nothing wrong with that. Of course, I am joking. It is a nice built in gamey 'feature' that allows 'scouting' for good places without risky anything. Does Steve go into a hissy fit regarding that? Of course not. It would take coding again. No coding. I said "NO CODING!!!".

I am also thinking that it is not just the coding but it would also 'look' funky. Basically a field of squares (tiles).

Steve is so off base on this, so entrenched now into a silly argument, that nothing can be positive. Its said in Sales "You can't sell anything to an irrational person". Especially when they watch The Simpsons and think that Surprise! and Zen have any bearing.

Is there any doubt that the whole Realtime fiasco was not Steve's Zen brainstorm?
 

NUTTERNAME

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,943
Reaction score
37
Location
N
Country
llVietnam
I read something recently where Steve said that he proclaimed that he issued most orders while in the "overhead view". Since he plays RT and issues orders like that...I suspect that he is actually playing 'Close Combat'....not Combat Mission.
 
Top