Which isn't significant if all the records are pulled into the Archive.
Without ROAR, they could not be pulled / have been pulled there, which was my point.
I always take this with a grain of salt. It's hard to know what the distribution of player skill across these games. Further, 20 playings doesn't feel "significant" to me. And more and more, seeing 20+ playings reported for anything means it is either > 2 years old or was played at a reported tournament.
Let us say that currently we see the publication of ~100 Scenarios by respectable publishers per year not counting possible CGs.
My estimate is that maybe 5% of all ASLers play that many scenarios.
My next estimate is that the number of ASLers playing less than 20-40 scenarios per year is greater than those playing more.
I think that a scenario being > 2 years old before being played is the norm rather than the exception.
"Significance" is gained gradually. Personally, I think that beginning with 20 playings, significance is beginning.
That said, I would assign a higher significance to a A: 19 / D: 1 result compared to a A: 10 / D: 10 result.
In any case, the higher the number of playings, the greater the distribution of player skill will become.
That said, I believe there is a higher tendency of playings among opponents whose skillset does not differ wildly rather than the opposite.
Which leads me to believe that a higher number of playings also leads to better clues on balance across various skill levels of play.
I think if a scenario is selected for a tournament, its chances for being balanced is higher. First of all, the TDs are usually experienced and might have a gut feeling for even new and previously unplayed scenarios. Furthermore, they will tend to select scenarios from respected publishers, which in turn tend to be better playtested. A scenario being played at a tournament adds a batch of playings to the database. Which, in turn, attracts more people to play it (following the herd, so to say).
I will take the word of a trusted friend on "fun" over both the Archive and ROAR. I will play CH based on input from a trusted friend. Anonymous "fun factor" on ROAR is meaningless to me personally. I am happy for you if you find it worthwhile.
I can follow that.
However, chances are that your trusted friend has not played most recently published scenarios.
For those he has not played, you can have a look at the hivemind - which is more than nothing.
von Marwitz