Report Scenarios Played to ROAR or ASL Archives

Augie

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
768
Reaction score
257
Location
Florida
Country
llUnited States
I reported my ASLOK playings in ROAR. What is the value for Players, Tourney TDs and Designers? To quote a line from "The Kingdom of Heaven"...."Nothing, and Everything". In other words, it can be useful but should to be taken with a grain of salt.
 

Vic Provost

Elder Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2016
Messages
2,134
Reaction score
5,313
Location
Pittsfield, MA USA
First name
Vic
Country
llUnited States
I reported my ASLOK playings in ROAR. What is the value for Players, Tourney TDs and Designers? To quote a line from "The Kingdom of Heaven"...."Nothing, and Everything". In other words, it can be useful but should to be taken with a grain of salt.
It is absolutely a great resource for the ASL Community, the more use it gets, the better it is for all of us.
 

Sparafucil3

Forum Legend
Joined
Oct 7, 2004
Messages
13,160
Reaction score
8,664
Location
USA
First name
Jim
Country
llUnited States
It is absolutely a great resource for the ASL Community, the more use it gets, the better it is for all of us.
What makes it better for us? There is no context around who is playing so as a balance mechanism. it is questionable at best. It let's us know what's popular, but with the explosion in options things don't get played over and over like they used to. So what benefits do you see from it? Personally, I only use it to look up where something came from so I can know if I have it or not. I haven't used it for balance, reporting, or much of anything else in a long while.

If I need something like ROAR, I tend to use the Scenario Archive. Not only can I see who played the games being reported, there is also an ability for the players to add notes and details about their playing. In addition to all of those benefits, it also has all the ROAR results loaded in.

So I am interested in why you think ROAR (or anything like) is a great resource.
 

von Marwitz

Forum Legend
Joined
Nov 25, 2010
Messages
16,540
Reaction score
14,228
Location
Kraut Corner
Country
llUkraine
ROAR is a great resource.

ROAR has recorded many more games than the ASL Scenario Archive.

While by now the ASL Scenario Archive also displays the ROAR ratings with a daily update, such updates used to be less frequent and the Archive did not also display ROAR ratings from the beginning.

Of course, the ASL Archive is newer and has much more to offer. But without ROAR, the ASL Scenario Archive would lack a good chunk of its data on playings.

While it may be wrong to expect the balance ratings to be an exact reflection of reality (which would be very hard to archieve, since it depends on whom plays whom), given a somewhat significant number of plays it does provide some general guidance.

If you are looking at some scenario with A: 15 / D: 5 I would readily place my bet that upon further play it would go rather to something like A: 30 / D: 10 than to A: 20 / D: 20.

Another factor for which both ROAR and the Archive are useful an a great resource is the Fun Rating.
Over the course of many years I can't remember coming across numerous scenarios with a Fun Rating of 7+ which I found boring while I found that number greater among scenarios with a Fun Rating of less than 6.

Especially with so many new stuff out there each year which even the most prolific players will struggle to keep up with, I don't see why I should hesitate giving a scenario with 20 playings and a fun rating of 7+ no preference over another one that does not. Usually, one's time for ASL is limited, and at least I play the chances to get the best out of this time.

von Marwitz
 

Sparafucil3

Forum Legend
Joined
Oct 7, 2004
Messages
13,160
Reaction score
8,664
Location
USA
First name
Jim
Country
llUnited States
ROAR has recorded many more games than the ASL Scenario Archive.
Which isn't significant if all the records are pulled into the Archive.

While it may be wrong to expect the balance ratings to be an exact reflection of reality (which would be very hard to archieve, since it depends on whom plays whom), given a somewhat significant number of plays it does provide some general guidance.

If you are looking at some scenario with A: 15 / D: 5 I would readily place my bet that upon further play it would go rather to something like A: 30 / D: 10 than to A: 20 / D: 20.
I always take this with a grain of salt. It's hard to know what the distribution of player skill across these games. Further, 20 playings doesn't feel "significant" to me. And more and more, seeing 20+ playings reported for anything means it is either > 2 years old or was played at a reported tournament.

Another factor for which both ROAR and the Archive are useful an a great resource is the Fun Rating.
Over the course of many years I can't remember coming across numerous scenarios with a Fun Rating of 7+ which I found boring while I found that number greater among scenarios with a Fun Rating of less than 6.

Especially with so many new stuff out there each year which even the most prolific players will struggle to keep up with, I don't see why I should hesitate giving a scenario with 20 playings and a fun rating of 7+ no preference over another one that does not. Usually, one's time for ASL is limited, and at least I play the chances to get the best out of this time.
I will take the word of a trusted friend on "fun" over both the Archive and ROAR. I will play CH based on input from a trusted friend. Anonymous "fun factor" on ROAR is meaningless to me personally. I am happy for you if you find it worthwhile.
 

von Marwitz

Forum Legend
Joined
Nov 25, 2010
Messages
16,540
Reaction score
14,228
Location
Kraut Corner
Country
llUkraine
Which isn't significant if all the records are pulled into the Archive.
Without ROAR, they could not be pulled / have been pulled there, which was my point.

I always take this with a grain of salt. It's hard to know what the distribution of player skill across these games. Further, 20 playings doesn't feel "significant" to me. And more and more, seeing 20+ playings reported for anything means it is either > 2 years old or was played at a reported tournament.
Let us say that currently we see the publication of ~100 Scenarios by respectable publishers per year not counting possible CGs.
My estimate is that maybe 5% of all ASLers play that many scenarios.
My next estimate is that the number of ASLers playing less than 20-40 scenarios per year is greater than those playing more.
I think that a scenario being > 2 years old before being played is the norm rather than the exception.

"Significance" is gained gradually. Personally, I think that beginning with 20 playings, significance is beginning.
That said, I would assign a higher significance to a A: 19 / D: 1 result compared to a A: 10 / D: 10 result.

In any case, the higher the number of playings, the greater the distribution of player skill will become.
That said, I believe there is a higher tendency of playings among opponents whose skillset does not differ wildly rather than the opposite.
Which leads me to believe that a higher number of playings also leads to better clues on balance across various skill levels of play.

I think if a scenario is selected for a tournament, its chances for being balanced is higher. First of all, the TDs are usually experienced and might have a gut feeling for even new and previously unplayed scenarios. Furthermore, they will tend to select scenarios from respected publishers, which in turn tend to be better playtested. A scenario being played at a tournament adds a batch of playings to the database. Which, in turn, attracts more people to play it (following the herd, so to say).

I will take the word of a trusted friend on "fun" over both the Archive and ROAR. I will play CH based on input from a trusted friend. Anonymous "fun factor" on ROAR is meaningless to me personally. I am happy for you if you find it worthwhile.
I can follow that.
However, chances are that your trusted friend has not played most recently published scenarios.
For those he has not played, you can have a look at the hivemind - which is more than nothing.

von Marwitz
 

Hutch

Curator of the ASL Armory
Joined
Feb 16, 2004
Messages
3,712
Reaction score
4,409
Location
FL
Country
llUnited States
One Note:
Dave made a change on the Scenario Archive, so that Random Scenario Names would not pop up on the ROAR Data.
This resulted in a reset of the Archives ROAR Listings.
You may have noticed that some scenarios are listed as the Scenario Name with Suggested Only, Choose/Confirm.
Enter the Scenario, check Scenario ID, and Confirm.
(Switch to proper sides if applicable)
Thanks...
 

igycrctl

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2017
Messages
218
Reaction score
93
Country
llUnited States
I report all of my plays in 3 places: ROAR, ASL Scenario Archive, and BGG. Mostly for redundancy. ASL Scenario Archive you own your recordings. ROAR the record is shared with your opponent and if they make changes or delete the record it deletes/changes it for you as well. BGG just because I record all of my plays of every game there, ASL or other games.
 

Vic Provost

Elder Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2016
Messages
2,134
Reaction score
5,313
Location
Pittsfield, MA USA
First name
Vic
Country
llUnited States
ROAR is a great resource.

ROAR has recorded many more games than the ASL Scenario Archive.

While by now the ASL Scenario Archive also displays the ROAR ratings with a daily update, such updates used to be less frequent and the Archive did not also display ROAR ratings from the beginning.

Of course, the ASL Archive is newer and has much more to offer. But without ROAR, the ASL Scenario Archive would lack a good chunk of its data on playings.

While it may be wrong to expect the balance ratings to be an exact reflection of reality (which would be very hard to archieve, since it depends on whom plays whom), given a somewhat significant number of plays it does provide some general guidance.

If you are looking at some scenario with A: 15 / D: 5 I would readily place my bet that upon further play it would go rather to something like A: 30 / D: 10 than to A: 20 / D: 20.

Another factor for which both ROAR and the Archive are useful an a great resource is the Fun Rating.
Over the course of many years I can't remember coming across numerous scenarios with a Fun Rating of 7+ which I found boring while I found that number greater among scenarios with a Fun Rating of less than 6.

Especially with so many new stuff out there each year which even the most prolific players will struggle to keep up with, I don't see why I should hesitate giving a scenario with 20 playings and a fun rating of 7+ no preference over another one that does not. Usually, one's time for ASL is limited, and at least I play the chances to get the best out of this time.

von Marwitz
I could not agree more. ROAR Is WAY Better than nothing, as is the Scenario archive, that is for sure.
 

fenyan

Elder Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2004
Messages
1,023
Reaction score
2,208
Location
California
Country
llUnited States
ROAR isn't going to keep me from playing a scenario of interest, of course if the win/loss is > 60%, I'll discuss with my opponent if we want to use the balance and often we end up playing it straight up anyhow.

I do like the ROAR recommendation rating (too bad it's another click to see it) as well as the comments in ASL Scenario Archive.
 

Andrew Rogers

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2010
Messages
202
Reaction score
623
Location
Canberra, Australia
First name
Andy
Country
llAustralia
ROAR and the ASLArchive are great resources when you are trying to run tournaments and select scenarios. Even if you are sceptical about the accuracy, generally speaking, it is a good 'canary-in-the-coal-mine' for unbalanced dogs.
 
Top