WW2 film "Saints and Soldiers"

Patrocles

Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
1,794
Reaction score
6
Location
Chicago, IL
Is this really a mormon film as described in the first paragraph of the review?

Most reviews and comments on SaS pretty negative even though it won 13 awards at small, unfamiliar, film festivals. The film looks great but apparently most folks have a hard time accepting the plot.

Has anyone here seen it? please post your review.


Asking Familiar Questions on the Battlefield
By DANA STEVENS

Published: October 15, 2004


War is heck in the clean-scrubbed world of "Saints and Soldiers," the best low-budget, Mormon World War II epic you'll see this year. If that sounds like faint praise, consider the 14 awards the film has garnered at festivals across the country, including seven prizes for audience choice. As the tag line "There is a time for heroes" suggests, this is an old-fashioned, crowd-pleasing war picture, unambivalent in its portrait of war as a necessity and the heroism of self-sacrifice. At a time when the country is divided over these very issues, it should find an enthusiastic, if limited, audience.

The film opens in December 1944 near Malmedy, Belgium, as advancing German troops open fire on unarmed American prisoners of war, killing 86 in an event that would become known as the Malmedy Massacre. The four men who manage to escape into the nearby Ardennes forest represent a conveniently diverse cross section of war-movie archetypes: the tough-talking sergeant (Peter Holden); the devout, soft-spoken sharpshooter (Corbin Allred); the wisecracking medic from Brooklyn (Alexander Niver); and the blundering Cajun country boy (Lawrence Bagby).

Trapped behind enemy lines with a single rifle among them, the soldiers strategize about how best to make their way to the nearest American Army camp. When a stranded R.A.F. pilot (Kirby Heyborne) drops in on them by parachute, the stakes are raised: the daffy Brit is in possession of German military intelligence that could save thousands of American lives. Together, the five men must overcome German snipers, frigid weather and long patches of expository dialogue to smuggle their precious cargo across enemy lines.

Thanks to an impressive cast of largely unknown actors, this small-scale, meticulously researched film tells its story with quiet conviction. The filmmaker's religious credo sneaks in so subtly that it's not until the closing credits that you realize that the "saints" of the title are of the Latter-day variety. A key exchange between the characters Gould, the atheist cynic, and Deacon, the tormented believer, poses the familiar question: Are the horrors of war proof of the universe's cruelty or a God-given opportunity to test our faith?

Unlike most war films of the last 30 years, this one plumps unapologetically for the latter option. Its strategy for dealing with the moral ambivalence of war — not to mention any parallels with contemporary conflicts — is to close its eyes, put down its head and charge. Darn the torpedoes, full speed ahead.

"Saints and Soldiers" opens today in Manhattan, Washington, Los Angeles and Phoenix. It is rated PG-13 (Parents strongly cautioned) and includes a sprinkling of very mild profanity, lots of war-related violence and one glimpse of a pinup girl on a playing card.

SAINTS AND SOLDIERS

Directed by Ryan Little; written by Geoffrey Panos and Matt Whitaker; edited by Wynn Hougaard; music by J. Bateman and Bart Hendrickson; production designer, Steven A. Lee; produced by Mr. Little and Adam Abel; released by Excel Entertainment Group. At the Loews 34th Street, 312 West 34th Street. Running time: 90 minutes. This film is rated PG-13.

WITH: Corbin Allred (Nathan ``Deacon'' Greer), Alexander Niver (Steven Gould), Peter Holden (Gordon Gunderson), Kirby Heyborne (Oberon Winley) and Lawrence Bagby (Shirl Kendrick).
 

Patrocles

Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
1,794
Reaction score
6
Location
Chicago, IL
gobeavs said:
Its not really an LDS (mormon) film, it was just done by some mormon people. If that constitutes a mormon film though, I guess it is :D.

The director/producer is mormon, and the other producer is mormon.

http://www.ldsfilm.com/SS/SaintsAndSoldiers.html
haha!

thanks for the link.
Hey, some of the nicest people I met are mormons! But I never lived in Utah and I heard it can be difficult in SLC if you are not a mormon.

Every director brings 'baggage' to his film vision and it would be interesting to see what the director/producer bought to this film!
 

Richa333

Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2004
Messages
86
Reaction score
0
Location
Olympia, WA
Country
llUnited States
JeremyScott said:
mormons are cool. gotta love the women :D
A-MEN, Jeremey!!! I have yet to meet a Mormon (active or Jack) that I haven't admired & liked, and that includes those young "Elder" boys that come a-visitin'.

And the WOMEN! Whoooo, don't get me started!!! WHUF WHOOF WHOOOOF AROOOO Oh yeah :devious:
 

gobeavs

Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
1,860
Reaction score
0
Location
West Coast USA
Country
llUnited States
Richa333 said:
A-MEN, Jeremey!!! I have yet to meet a Mormon (active or Jack) that I haven't admired & liked, and that includes those young "Elder" boys that come a-visitin'.
Glad that you like our missionaries :D...I may just be one come 4 years..

But aside from religion, I hope this movie comes to our area.
 
Last edited:

Richa333

Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2004
Messages
86
Reaction score
0
Location
Olympia, WA
Country
llUnited States
gobeavs said:
Glad that you like our missionaries :D...I may just be one come 4 years..
Excellent! There's a good friend of mine, now grown & married w/children etc, an active Mormon, who still speaks fondly of his experiences on mission. If there's even a slight chance of gaining enough funding from your family, angle for an international posting ... go for it! :cheeky:
 

Patrocles

Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
1,794
Reaction score
6
Location
Chicago, IL
gobeavs said:
Glad that you like our missionaries :D...I may just be one come 4 years..

But aside from religion, I hope this movie comes to our area.
Portland is progressive so the chances are good the film will be in your area!

post a review.
 
Joined
Jan 21, 2004
Messages
413
Reaction score
0
Location
Fairfax, Va
I don't see why the Mormon attachment is meant to construe that it can't be a good "war movie" as well. Mormons have always believed in the right of armed defense. Arguably the greatest gun designer of all time, John Moses Browning, was Mormon. What's the big deal?
 

Patrocles

Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
1,794
Reaction score
6
Location
Chicago, IL
Lance Williams said:
I don't see why the Mormon attachment is meant to construe that it can't be a good "war movie" as well. Mormons have always believed in the right of armed defense. Arguably the greatest gun designer of all time, John Moses Browning, was Mormon. What's the big deal?
I don't think anyone has stated it is a good or bad film because it is by a mormon director. At least I haven't heard any comments in that vein. If you do, don't believe 'em!

From what I have read the critics and film buffs say the plot and dialogue is bit hard to swallow. Who knows maybe we will like it once we see it.

(And wasn't there a "Mormon Brigade" in the Mexican-American war? or was that WW2? IIRC, this was a tough bunch of fighters.)
 
Top