The only thing even near that is the Destroyer counter in LFT's OP:Ch StN. That was just about acceptable because it was a single counter. While some like me have the knowledge, tools, practice and skills from other previous hobby work to do a decently neat job, many, maybe most, do not. Cardboard can be quite tricky to cut. You probably have read the debates about counter clipping. As a group we are fairly anal about square counters and counter hues/shades, so having to manually cut out (as opposed to slicing small nibs) will go down like a gallon bag of puke.
I have done a tiny number of my own counters, not too bad, but not quite as good as MMP/BFP/LFT ones. This is not a desktop published game. ASLers like their counters crisp and reasonably easy to extract. They have an enormous rulebook to digest, they don't need additional hassle.