The First Games--AH versus SPI
Here's an old, old debate I'd not seen in a while....
Which games did people like when they were first playing wargames? For me, it was the Avalon Hill wargames. I just had an easier time getting into them and playing them, for the most part. SPI games were downright scary and generally something you aspired to play.
Referencing my earliest post, my first game was MIDWAY. Well, for Christmas my Dad got me SPI's THE FAST CARRIERS. It came with a paper map in a flat plastic box and tons of complicated-looking counters and--what seemed to me--a big fat rulebook.
Now, I'd also gotten a copy of THIRD REICH from Avalon Hill which looked equally intimidating. But the ad copy on the back of the box pretty much trumpeted the game as the ultimate simulation, if I remember correctly. And I knew not all AH games were like that.
But the ad copy on the back flap of THE FAST CARRIERS wasn't as reassuring. And many of the other SPI games I'd seen my new-found wargame friends cart around seemed similiarly complicated (USN is one good example). Oh, I tackled FAST CARRIERS and even enjoyed it...but it took all weekend to play a scenario between me and a buddy. We were left breathless by the experience and marveled at the game more than played it after that.
Funny thing was, SPI had plenty of "players" there in its collection of titles. But I didn't get that exposure for quite some time. When I became a senior, I got a copy of THE MOSCOW CAMPAIGN and found it very manageable and quite fun to play. It was only then I got a subscription to S&T and a whole new world opened up to me.
I will say this--and it's no surprise to anyone who played games back then. SPI had some brilliant designs, but they also had a lot of "dogs." AH seemed to have far fewer of the latter, even if they didn't exactly seem to be on the cutting edge of game design. I bought a lot of games from both companies, but ended up playing mostly AH titles with other people; solitairing or simply studying the components of the SPI games.
I think the company knew this and that's why they got into the "quad" games that were easy to pick up and fun to play. Some of my best memories were playing NAPOLEON'S LAST BATTLES Quadrigame and BATTLES FOR THE ARDENNES Quad and "Arnhem" from the WESTWALL QUAD. Even some of the full-size games were good players, although I had to uncover them: PANZERGRUPPE GUDERIAN being the most famous, I'd imagine, but also the old TURNING POINT: STALINGRAD, CONQUISTADOR, PANZERARMEE AFRIKA, etc.
Sadly, we don't seem to have quite this accessibility/variety for neophytes to cut their teeth on these days....
--emw