What Topic Don't You Want to See Done in ASL

[wrongway149]

PTO - Wake island, Saipan...

Rich

No more PTO 'bug hunts', please.

This is what scares me about Manila.

 

[BobO]

Hi-

I want to see d20 ASL

I dont want to see alternative WWII ASL. Whats next? A Detroit CG called into the Auto Factory?


Scott

You think Stalingrad was brutal... wait till you see inner city Detroit squads and their MOL capabilities.

 

[Hovned31]

Wars of the Reformation. I'm just not very happy with the way that Tercios handle using ASL rules.

 

[paulkenny]

no more brits attacking bridges!

unless it is cool

 

[Ruarigh]

No more desert/night scenarios mixed into packs/HASL. Roar shows virtually no one plays them.

I would like Vietnam, jungle action, more firepower, a fight against evil communists... PTO - Wake island, Saipan...

Rich

Sounds like you want everything I am fed up of seeing, and don't want the stuff I do want! I love the desert and think that there should be more desert and less jungle, but I have never habitually posted my results to ROAR. Oh well, I know whose interests are more likely to be catered to.

Cheers,
Ruarigh

 

[MrP]

No more US paratroops in Normandy. Not hugely keen on Eastern Front stuff either (heresy!)
Everything else, bring it on.

 

[ScoobySnacks]

Anything outside WW2

I think Market Garden has pretty much been done to death. Stalingrad can see a nice break for a while with the release of VotG.

 

[pdutram]

Actually, I'd be interested in both of these. But didn't someone already do a 1918 scenario?

Four of them in fact:
Breakout (Belgium)
First Sting (East Africa)
The Fox's First Bite (Argonne)
Teufelhunden (Belleau Wood)

See the first four entries in the Master ASL Scenario Listing for details.

 

[Earthpig]

No Sci FI but other than that I'm OK

 

[footsteps]

Nothing outside of say 1935 - 1956.

I second that sentiment.

hors d'œuvres: Spanish Civil War; Sino-Japanese War
main course: WW2
hangover: Arab/Israeli Wars

Alan

 

[Pitman]

The Chinese Civil War and Korea are probably a bit bigger hangovers than the 1948 war!

 

[Eagle4ty]

Stick to the venue that SL/ASL was originally created for: WW-II! Spain?Well it was so much of a pre-cursor (a primer for tactics as it were) for WWII, I don't see how this could be excluded. Same goes for Russo-Japanese and Chinese-Japananese conflicts of the late 30's. Chinese Civil War, Communist insurgencies in Greece and Yougoslavia, Korea, Post WW-II French Indo-China etc could be done with comparative ease, but stay away from these as "Official" packs as the scope of the project doesn't seem to suggest this is where the designers were headed. :stop:

However, I wasn't one of the guys putting this thing together and I don't know for certain what their long term goals were. For myself, though these are interesting conflicts from a historical perspective, I would not be inclined to spend money or time on such projects.aperbag:

Well you did ask!

 

[Gunner Scott]

Hi-

As waird as it may seem, the Iraqi war conflict 2003 to now can possibly be gamed using ASL since most of the actions have been infantry. On the other hand, I would personally find it kind of waird gaming in a conflict I was actually in.


Scott

 

[Eagle4ty]

:smoke: Well, never used ASL as it was simply too much to drag around, but did use similar games to help "ADVISE" my IQ counterparts and CDRs on tactics, planning, and get them to realize potential pitfalls of operations. The AC General scenarios were enjoyed by one and all and used frequently. We even used the game ToA during a Leadership Developement course for them to explain "Cordon & Serach".

But I agree! Not too much intrest there for me to have ASL reflect more modren actions - at least to play them. More interested in the history of the usual situations (And I'm a WW-II nut!).:nuts:

 

[Pitman]

Hi-

As waird as it may seem, the Iraqi war conflict 2003 to now can possibly be gamed using ASL since most of the actions have been infantry. On the other hand, I would personally find it kind of waird gaming in a conflict I was actually in.


Scott

Weren't you a guard?

 

[Sparafucil3]

Weren't you a guard?

I believe he was an MP. -- jim

 

[Darrell Andersen]

"Weren't you a guard?"

While I am the first to make fun of Holst for his leg, MP status please keep in mind that this conflict has been tough on almost all military jobs.

The time away from home is worth our respect, regardless of combat role.

Now back to standard Holst bashing.

 

[footsteps]

The Chinese Civil War and Korea are probably a bit bigger hangovers than the 1948 war!

Oops, forgot those! Guess I've got G48 on my mind. Yes, I agree that those conflicts also fit into my "hangover" category, and I would like to see them all -- at some point off in the future -- as MMP ASL products.

Alan

 

[JRKrejsa]

Another vote for no more Market-Garden, at least for a few years.

Bring on Spanish Civil War and Korea!

 

[sswann]

Hi-

As waird as it may seem, the Iraqi war conflict 2003 to now can possibly be gamed using ASL since most of the actions have been infantry. On the other hand, I would personally find it kind of waird gaming in a conflict I was actually in.


Scott

That is my problem with Viet Nam.