Tuomo
Keeper of the Funk
How many times, and do you have a winning record?
Cue JR with the Wintergewitter flashbacks.
Cue JR with the Wintergewitter flashbacks.
What Scenario Have You Played The Most?
- Thread starter Tuomo
- Start date
Craig Benn
Senior Member
Kempf at Melikhovo I reckon. I've won more than I've lost but I couldn't give exact numbers. Maybe played it 7-9 times.
It's a really nice filler if you finish a big scenario early and have a couple of hours to kill. A couple of toys on either side even though OBs are small. Dicey of course.
Having said that, been years since I played it. Very rare to play scenarios more than once anymore except maybe twice for tournaments (one practice, one for real).
It's a really nice filler if you finish a big scenario early and have a couple of hours to kill. A couple of toys on either side even though OBs are small. Dicey of course.
Having said that, been years since I played it. Very rare to play scenarios more than once anymore except maybe twice for tournaments (one practice, one for real).
Tom Morin
Senior Member
Bread Factory #2. Probably close to 50-50 on outcomes.
- Joined
- Feb 4, 2003
- Messages
- 4,654
- Reaction score
- 4,203
- Location
- La Belle Province
- First name
- Michael
- Country
-
I went through this exercise a few years ago, but I can't find the results. I remember, however, that Guards Counterattack and Totsugeki were at the top of the list.
Rocket's Red Glare. Easy, no contest. At least 14 playing's that I know of. 13-1, mostly as the German, but Ralph MacDonald got me as the Americans. The late Gary Trezza used to tease me about being a professional Rockets Red Glare player 
. I truly do miss Gary.
. I truly do miss Gary.
daveramsey
Elder Member
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2006
- Messages
- 1,816
- Reaction score
- 1,051
- Location
- Hertfordshire
- First name
- Dave
- Country
-
I have 6 playings of L'Hérrison, yet all I ever remember about that scenario is German-French city fight with some 150mm AFVs rolling around. I'm 4-2 with 3 playings each side, and split evenly amongst wins and losses when defending and attacking.
Doug Kirk
Senior Member
Rockets Red Glare 6 times.
Death at Carentan and Acts of Defiance 5 times each.
A dozen or more scenarios at 4 times each.
Death at Carentan and Acts of Defiance 5 times each.
A dozen or more scenarios at 4 times each.
JR Brackin
Cardboard Challanged
Totsogecki - 0-2 in Playtest, 4-1 in regular gaming
Vic Provost
Forum Guru
- Joined
- Sep 18, 2016
- Messages
- 1,501
- Reaction score
- 3,410
- Location
- Pittsfield, MA USA
- First name
- Vic
- Country
-
I go with the same scenario, have to have played it close to 20 times all together with extremely mixed results, blowouts for both sides and tight games coming down to the last CC roll. The German might have a small advantage, I think they won just over half of those playings. The scenario is just so close and the Russian is often praying he can hold on until the reinforcements arrive. I'd play this again, either side, vs anyone. Roll low and have FUN!
lionelc62
Senior Member
- Joined
- Nov 16, 2007
- Messages
- 410
- Reaction score
- 452
- Location
- Northern France
- First name
- Lionel
- Country
-
J103 Lenin's Sons. Probably played it 6-7 times (good to teach new players DC / FT).
rdw5150
it's just a game
I tend not to play a scenario more that a couple of times. I am not a big "tourney" guy so not really a lot of repeats there, and usually want to play something new (or large).
I know I have played White Tigers 4 times. 2-2.
I played Merzenhausen Zoo three times (in a row with Burnie as a study of it) and ever so sadly went 0-3.
Played Puma Prowls three times (again in a row as a study, all in one game night) and went 2-1.
I played Maggot Hill 3 times and went 1-1-1 (the tie being due to a rare instance of FOBA (Feline OBA).
One of the things I regret in my ASL career is not keeping track of each playing I have had. Way too late to worry about that now.
Peace
Roger
I know I have played White Tigers 4 times. 2-2.
I played Merzenhausen Zoo three times (in a row with Burnie as a study of it) and ever so sadly went 0-3.
Played Puma Prowls three times (again in a row as a study, all in one game night) and went 2-1.
I played Maggot Hill 3 times and went 1-1-1 (the tie being due to a rare instance of FOBA (Feline OBA).
One of the things I regret in my ASL career is not keeping track of each playing I have had. Way too late to worry about that now.
Peace
Roger
Steve E7
Senior Member
For me its a tie between VotG10- The Darkest Day and Merzenhausen Zoo , 4 playings each
Thunderchief
Elder Member
These are my scenarios with the highest playings:
ASL 14 - Silence that Gun (3-1)
ASL 22 - Kurhaus Clash (2-2)
J 111 - Prussia in Flames (3-1)
J 60 - Bad Luck (0-5)
ASL 14 - Silence that Gun (3-1)
ASL 22 - Kurhaus Clash (2-2)
J 111 - Prussia in Flames (3-1)
J 60 - Bad Luck (0-5)
bendizoid
Official ***** Dickweed
Looks like some good luck and some bad luck.
Actionjick
Forum Guru
- Joined
- Apr 23, 2020
- Messages
- 7,618
- Reaction score
- 5,117
- Location
- Kent, Ohio
- First name
- Darryl
- Country
-
Guards Counterattack
Guryev's Headquarters
Strayer's Strays
Probably Strayer's was played the most. We played it over ten times in one session. Wham! Bam! Thank you jick.
Guryev's Headquarters
Strayer's Strays
Probably Strayer's was played the most. We played it over ten times in one session. Wham! Bam! Thank you jick.
waltu
Member
Fighting Withdrawal - 5 times, won 3, lost 2.
For some reason that one comes back to haunt me time and again, and not thorough my choosing.
For some reason that one comes back to haunt me time and again, and not thorough my choosing.
A69 Action at Balberkamp
We must've played this one well over a dozen times (probably closer to 20) back in the day when we had an active 4-5 player local SL/ASL group. It was ideal for multi-player action....
Lots of great memories associated with this scenario.
We must've played this one well over a dozen times (probably closer to 20) back in the day when we had an active 4-5 player local SL/ASL group. It was ideal for multi-player action....
Lots of great memories associated with this scenario.
wrongway149
Forum Guru
This one is my 'Wintergrwitter'. Played at least half a dozen times as both sides -- only losses.
volgaG68
Fighting WWII One DR At A Time
- Joined
- Jun 15, 2012
- Messages
- 3,212
- Reaction score
- 1,551
- Location
- La Crosse, KS
- First name
- Chris
- Country
-
Strangers In A Strange Land from CdG, probably close to 10 times. About as close to 'perfect' as you can get in a small scenario, IMO. Well balanced, little bits of chrome, and fun. Quite a few different possible defenses and attack strategies for such a small scenario. Always comes down to the wire. I can't recall any other scenario I've played more than three times.
Paul John
Senior Member
I have played 'Old Friends' 5 times. It's a great one to work on my nemesis, American combined arms attacks.