I don't know any of those games, and not being a console owner/player I am at best a limited opinion.
But from what I have seen of friends gaming, I would likely rank car games, sports games, shooters in that order normally.
That's because when I visit, I seem willing to play a car game, sports games seem to be the most engaging (I'll only watch though), and shooters, well they seem boringly repetative oriented solo or online (and I have no interest in playing them at all).