Libertalia - my group liked it so much they wanted to play again, which is always the best sign. 30 different pirates fighting over booty. Great theme, lots of strategy, great game.
They are completely different games. Elder Signs is a basic roll the dice and match the symbols to defeat the bad guys game. Not much to it. Arkham Horror is a much deeper and longer game. I had to sell my copy of AH, because my group likes games that play in the 1-2 hour range. AH can take 4-5 hours, but with the right crowd can be an immersive and fun experience.I have Elder Signs: Omens on my phone which I understand is similar to Arkham Horror. Somehow I think Arkham Horror must be better, because I really don't care for Elder Signs... How would you compare them?