CM maps: they should be interesting and challenging, but not too tough (river crossing). I guess the best would be if we simply alternate the maps and forces between the players. Lets assume for round1 we have team1, the attacker and team two, the defender. Lets assume 4 players for each side.
Than the first setting would be attack on map1 with force1 (germany?) against force2 (soviet?)
next pairing: attacking on map1 with force2 against force1
next: attacking on map2 with force1 vs force2
next: attacking on map2 with force2 vs force1
That would give us the best mix possible and no side could claim that the map was biased agaist them or that the attacking force was unbeatable because they had the better stuff etc.
Next round would be: all players who played on map1 during the first round as the attacker will than defend on map2 and the other way around.
Maybe we could make a mixed TOAW/CM tournament (so that nobody gets left behind because he doesn't have a game), after all the main point is to get both former forums to play against each other to beat the living sh... ah, to get to know each other better