sunday 21.03.2010 us/european battle - en passant revised

bolitho

Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2008
Messages
88
Reaction score
0
Location
Heidelberg
Country
llGermany
honorable Lords of the admirality,

the following battle report is the translation of the german battle report transmitted by our secret agent "Madame X" in Berlin.

Report from the commander of the battleships of the high seas fleet:
In the late afternoon of 21.03.1916 a heavy battle was fought between parts of our high seas fleet and the british grand fleet. Our ships are at the coast of holland with course NE when in NW british light cruisers came into sight. Cruiser Wiesbaden was told to find out which forces are approaching.
The following drawing represent the situation at this time.
View attachment 29387
Shortly after this british BC (Lion and Tiger) came into sight, our BC were ordered to attack. As behind the yet known british ships the GF may be present our battleships turned to west to attack them from the south. In the following 20 minutes the GF showed up and the battle lines decreased distance on converging course 270. Our BC came under heavy fire from 4 british 38cm (15in) battleships of the queen elizabeth class.
View attachment 29388
Lateron the QE were also the first RN ships changing salvos with our battleships. The heavy calibre resulted in a number of fatal hits on Kronprinz magazine which exploded. Thüringen also suffered a number of 38cm hits which caused heavy flooding. Oldenburg got a hit in the steering which resulted in a jammed rudder. There must be a mysterious connection between the steering and the external communication which caused that no further target-commands could be given to the Oldenburg and other ships with jammed rudder. Our SES-engineers have to look at this. At this time no heavy damage could be observed on the RN side. Our ships suffered a number of destroyed turrets decreasing the strength of our fire.
View attachment 29389
After the battle we got reports from british survivors of some sunk destroyers which refused to talk first but under the influence of some bottles of white-beer (rem.: new german secret-drug?) they told us that at this time already the BB Iron Duke and Ajax were sunk. Our ship Kaiserin exploded suddenly, maybe due to a hit in the magazine. Koenig Albert was hit by a number of salvos and it was clear that the leakage couldn´t be fixed in the open waters. A few minutes later Thüringen sunk due her heavy damage from the first 38cm hits. Our DD performed a torpedo attack, the report about this will follow seperately.
Our ships were ordered for heading home at NE still targetting the enemy. As direct success our rangefinder-operators could observe one QE, propably Warspite, blowing up. Unfortunately Markgraf got a hit causing a jammed rudder and had to be left circling behind the line. A number of ships used the opportunity to target the Markgraf, even a flotilla of destroyers tried to sink her. But the brave Markgraf opened fire from all guns and the torpedo attack was annihilated. About half of the attacking destroyers were sunk by the secondary artillery. It seems that the RN torpedo targetting had difficulty getting the correct fire-solution for a circling ship. A number of british AC sent a rain of grenades to the Markgraf resulting loosing one turret from the two left. Nevertheless the leading AC Defense was hit a number of times by Markgrafs brave cannoniers.
View attachment 29390
The end of the battle was characterized by a number of fightings between RN DD and our CL, even resulting in hitting our again-maneuvrable Oldenburg by one of our own torpedos. Brave von der Tann was also hit badly resulting in her later loss.
special honors to DD B98 for rescuing the survivors of Koenig Albert and Thüringen despite badly leaking!
Also to mention that during battle all overseas communication worked fine and without problems of the secret hamachi device.


List of losses:
Kaiserin (expl)
König Albert
Thüringen
Kronprinz (expl)
von der Tann

destroyers:
V44
V45
V46
V71
B97
G104

The british may have lost about the same number of ships, we are waiting for a report from our intelligence for further details.

signed:
Admiral Hipper (light forces)
von der Tann (BC)
bolitho (BB)
- end of the german report -

honorable Lords,
unfortunately we lost a even more ships as the germans, her is the full report:

Warspite (expl)
Iron Duke (expl)
Marlborough
Erin
King George V
Centurion
Ajax
Orion
Monarch
Colossus

AC Defense
CL Birmingham

destroyers:
Ariel
Goshawk
Laurel
Lydiard
Nerissa
Pelican
Narborough
Nestor
Nomad

our special memories to Sir John Jellicoe who sunk with Iron Duke

signed for the GF

Anav
Invincible
 
Joined
Jul 15, 2009
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
Location
Germany
Country
llGermany
Nice report.

My torpedo attacks were unfortunately not so successful. The most torpedos, which were fired at the BBs, running in front of the passing ships. Probably they reduced their Speed.
The only success was signed by the III. Half-Flottila. At the end of battle they fired their torpedos against the BCF. It seems that CL Birmingham was at the false time at the false place. She must have been hit by an torpedo.

PS: I have some problems with some english words, I hope you can read it. :laugh:
 

Von der Tann

Schlachtkreuzer
Joined
Oct 2, 2008
Messages
719
Reaction score
1
Location
Münster
Country
llGermany
'twas a mighty battle indeed... I am truly surprised that of my brave heavy cavalry only Von der Tann didn't make it home.

We scanned the log files for the hit statistics for our ships (a big Thank you to rgreat for the analyser!), and we'd be very interested in the counterparts from the British admiralty files.

Von der Tann's ships:

Lützow
004 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
003 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
005 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
023 x 12 inch Mk XI Gun.
040 x 6in BL Mk XVI Gun.
005 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.
034 x 6in BL Mk XIII Gun.
005 x 12-pdr 12cwt QF Mk II.
026 x 12 inch Mk XIII Gun.

3 critical hits.

Derfflinger
003 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
021 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
004 x 12 inch Mk XI Gun.
022 x 4in BL Mk VII Gun.
002 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.

3 critical hits.

Seydlitz
016 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
003 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
025 x 12 inch Mk XIII Gun.
010 x 4in BL Mk VII Gun.

1 critical hits.

Moltke
002 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
016 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
015 x 4in BL Mk VII Gun.
156 x 6in BL Mk XVI Gun.
002 x 12-pdr 20cwt HA Mk I.

1 critical hits.

Von der Tann (sank after battle)
004 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
014 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
007 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
001 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.

Pillau
001 x 12-pdr 20cwt HA Mk I.

Elbing
001 x 12-pdr 20cwt HA Mk I.
002 x 6in BL Mk XI(PVI) Gun.

Wiesbaden
012 x 4in QF Mk V Gun.
007 x 6in BL Mk XII(PVII) Gun.
002 x 6in BL Mk XII(CP) Gun.


V 46 (sunk)
004 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.
001 x 12-pdr 20cwt HA Mk I.
004 x 6in BL Mk XIII Gun.
002 x 12-pdr 12cwt QF Mk II.
003 x 6in BL Mk XVI Gun.
001 x 3in 45cal QF Gun.
003 x 4in BL Mk VII Gun.

2 critical hits.

V 45 (sunk)
002 x 4in QF Mk V Gun.
001 x 4in BL Mk VII Gun.
002 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.
006 x 6in BL Mk XI(PVI) Gun.
034 x 2-pdr Mk II Pom-pom.
013 x 4in QF Mk IV Gun.

3 critical hits.

V 44 (sunk)
003 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.
003 x 12-pdr 12cwt QF Mk II.
138 x 4in QF Mk IV Gun.
095 x 2-pdr Mk II Pom-pom.
010 x 1-pdr Pom-pom.

20 critical hits.


Bolitho's ships:

Helgoland
003 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
010 x 12 inch Mk XI Gun.
004 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
001 x 50cm G7 Torpedo

Ostfriesland
009 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
007 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.

3 critical hits.

Thüringen (sunk)
017 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.

5 critical hits.

Oldenburg
011 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
001 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.

1 critical hits.

Kaiser
002 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
002 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
012 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.

2 critical hits.

Friedrich der Grosse
004 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
003 x 12 inch Mk XI Gun.
008 x 12-pdr 12cwt QF Mk II.
004 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.

Kaiserin - expl -
017 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.

2 critical hits.


König Albert (sunk)
024 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
022 x 13.5in Mk VI Gun.

4 critical hits.

Prinzregent Luitpold
002 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
018 x 13.5in Mk VI Gun.
004 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
004 x 12 inch Mk XIII Gun.

1 critical hits.

König
013 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
003 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
004 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.

4 critical hits.

Grosser Kurfürst
019 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
002 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
001 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.

1 critical hits.

Markgraf
014 x 13.5in Mk V 1400 lb Gun.
008 x 12 inch Mk XI Gun.
004 x 15 inch Mk I Gun.
010 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
016 x 6in BL Mk VII(H) Gun.
002 x 2-pdr Mk II Pom-pom.
021 x 4in QF Mk IV Gun.
030 x 7.5in BL Mk II Gun.
026 x 6in BL Mk XI(PV) Gun.
019 x 12-pdr 18cwt QF Mk I.
015 x 9.2 inch Mk X Gun.
006 x 9.2 inch Mk XI Gun.
010 x 3-pdr QF Mk I / V Gun.

5 critical hits.

Kronprinz - expl -
010 x 12 inch Mk XI Gun.

1 critical hits.

Admiral Hipper's ships:

Rostock
001 x 13.5in Mk V 1250 lb Gun.
009 x 12-pdr 12cwt QF Mk II.
001 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.

B97 (sunk)
008 x 6in BL Mk XI(PVI) Gun.
001 x 12-pdr 20cwt HA Mk I.

G104 (sunk)
001 x 7.5in BL Mk II Gun.
001 x 9.2 inch Mk X Gun.
002 x 6in BL Mk XI(PVI) Gun.

G42
010 x 6in BL Mk XI(PVI) Gun.
001 x 4in BL Mk VIII Gun.

B98
001 x 6in BL Mk VII(H) Gun.
003 x 7.5in BL Mk II Gun.
001 x 12-pdr 20cwt HA Mk I.
001 x 6in BL Mk XI(PVI) Gun.
 

Von der Tann

Schlachtkreuzer
Joined
Oct 2, 2008
Messages
719
Reaction score
1
Location
Münster
Country
llGermany
From my point of view, the battle went like this:

At first, we decided to try and attack the enemy van from two sides, which is why the BCF first went on a NW course. Seeing that the RN forces were too far up N for this, I turned to SW and engaged the leading capital ships, which turned out to be the RN battlecruisers reinforced by the 5th Battle Squadron made up of Queen Elizabeth class BB. CL Wiesbaden strayed a bit too far and lay under fire from RN CL, receiving a number of 6" hits, but was able to retreat with no serious damage. A lengthy exchange of salvoes ensued while the RN forces swung to a SW course as well, and despite several hits, the BC performed magnificently, losing no turrets and receiving only minor flooding while scoring a number of hits on the RN QE and BC. With the German BL coming up behind me, I disengaged for a while and sailed behind the BL. My intention was to overtake the BL behind the line of battle and provide fire support until reaching the tip of our formation, but this plan was quickly dropped when our line started to get hit badly, and the BC swung on a WNW course to relieve the pressure. Ajax seems to have gone down to a magazine explosion fairly early, but the remaining ships of the Orion and King George V classes, reinforced by Agincourt, Erin and several older dreadnoughts started to hit us badly. Several turrets burned out and flooding increased, and when the BL reversed course to E-NE, the BC followed suit. Von der Tann was detached from the line, as she was the slowest ship, followed shortly by Lützow which had been slowed down considerably by the numerous hits. The other units continued to exchange fire with the enemy dreadnoughts, several of which were damaged and slowed down as well. A daring torpedo run seems to have scored some hits on the Colossus class ships, but the TB were lost later when they ran into a DD formation unattended, as I was busy elsewhere and had completely forgotten about them... poor sods :OHNO:. In the last half hour, the battle raged on with the ships of the Orion class, which had not received much damage until then, the badly damaged HMS Centurion and King George V plus Erin and Agincourt. Our battlecruisers received a great number of hits in a short time, and Agincourt continued to pour grenades on us, while our own salvoes aimed at her went astray for most of the time. But we seem to have scored some hits as well, the Orions slowed down, and one of them went up in an explosion - but Von der Tann had suffered too much damage and was lost on the way home.

One of the best battles in a long time for sure, heavy fighting with professionals on either side. One of the most remarkable things in the battle was the fact that the trans-atlantic connection was absolutely flawless. Why can't things be like this every day? I'd really enjoy more gaming with our American colleagues!

Great fighting, gentlemen, and a most enjoyable battle!
 
Top