Shiloh Or Franklin?

[foster]

Hello All

Which of these two game do you all perfer? I want to get a game that covers the western theater of the civil war but dont know which one of those two is the better game.

Thanks for your input.

 

[last_cav1971]

Not being much of a gamer, I would say historically that Shiloh would be the better one. Franklin was just too much of a debacle by Hood. Shiloh should be interesting.

Mark
Deo Vindice

 

[Boonierat]

Get Shiloh, big and small battles, huge campaign and lots of gunboats! :cheeky:

 

[Alex Krolikowsk]

I would go for Shiloh because it cover more battles.
Here is a review of this game:
www.strategyzoneonline.com/articles.php?p=549&page=1&cat=52

As to Franklin - it is also good, campaign game (Columbia/Spring Hill-Franklin-Nashville) is still my favorite. Playing it constantly :halo:

 

[last_cav1971]

I would go for Shiloh because it cover more battles.
Here is a review of this game:
www.strategyzoneonline.com/articles.php?p=549&page=1&cat=52

As to Franklin - it is also good, campaign game (Columbia/Spring Hill-Franklin-Nashville) is still my favorite. Playing it constantly :halo:

Like the Cleburne avatar.

Mark
Deo Vindice