S1 Victory Conditions

[Crender]

The scenario card says:
'The Americans win at game end if there are no Good Order German units in buildings N5, N6, M4, and L3.'

So, to win, do the Germans need to have GO units in ALL of those buildings or just one?

Thanks

 

[klasmalmstrom]

Just one I think...

 

[Crender]

Thanks
It was Neil Ulen of ASL Academy on YouTube who suggested it was all the buildings, he now agrees it is only one, so matter is closed.

 

[Hutch]

If they change the “and” to “or” it would make better sense.

 

[Stewart]

If they change the “and” to “or” it would make better sense.

But then the Americans would ONLY need to keep ONE building free of GO Germans...i.e. if ANY building simply didn't have a GO German in it...they would lose.

Whereas, the VC allows for any/all buildings to have Germans units it them...The Americans simply need to Jump ( and Remain) in CC and Remain in Melee at Game end.

It really makes a difference on the Game conditions ...the "and/or" usage.

 

[klasmalmstrom]

Perhaps something like this would have been clearer?

The Americans win at game end if neither of the following buildings contain a Good Order German unit(s): N5, N6, M4, and L3.