Rubble Clearance And Concealment

[volgaG68]

Nothing to see here, problem solved with a more thorough reading!

 

[Eagle4ty]

I guess I've always taken the route that once marked with a TI counter the unit was engaged in the act of clearing the obstacle (i.e. using Clearance) and would therefore be subject to concealment loss at the end of its MPh because it would be considered a moving unit utilizing all it MF to accomplish the task and would therefore be subject to concealment loss for that reason. However, you do raise a valid point by strict wording of the rules as presented, but believe if a clarification was warranted, it would come down on the side of concealment loss at the time it was declared and thus MF spent. JMHO.

 

[Binchois]

If it helps, A12.141 puts this case another way:

Any other activity which a concealed unit engages in...causes loss of concealment if that unit is currently in the LOS and within 16 hexes of a Good Order enemy ground unit. [This includes those who] "engage in Clearance attempts..."​

I think the loss occurs upon declaring the action.

 

[volgaG68]

I guess I've always taken the route that once marked with a TI counter the unit was engaged in the act of clearing the obstacle (i.e. using Clearance) and would therefore be subject to concealment loss at the end of its MPh because it would be considered a moving unit utilizing all it MF to accomplish the task and would therefore be subject to concealment loss for that reason. However, you do raise a valid point by strict wording of the rules as presented, but believe if a clarification was warranted, it would come down on the side of concealment loss at the time it was declared and thus MF spent. JMHO.

I deleted the post after a more thorough reading. If it must use ALL its MF to enter the rubble and declare its intent, it therefore could not be using Assault Movement.

 

[Eagle4ty]

...two Answers went in search of a Question...

Well I guess it's better than arguing against your better interests, each taking the others guy's POV on a pivotal shot!