G
Guest
Guest
This is twisting my mind....any help for the routing Russian? Is he elim for FTR? or can he Low Crawl away?
Regards,
Regards,
Reepicheep
Member
There seems to be a problem with the picture you posted. I'm just getting an Internet Explorer red "x" because the picture can't be found at the location you specified.
G
Guest
Guest
Yeah, it was there when I previewed the post....then it was gone....now I log-in and it's back. I'm not savvy enough with this stuff to say why it shows up sometimes and not others....
Perhaps someone more experienced with the forum could assist?
Perhaps someone more experienced with the forum could assist?
Count Belisarius
Member
Hi,
I get this problem with images not appearing all the time. Not sure on the cause but you can right click on the image,select properties and cut and paste the URL http://www.geocities.com/wrpinkley/rout.GIF into a new explorer window.
Not a solution but at least a workaround!
Cheers
Andy
I get this problem with images not appearing all the time. Not sure on the cause but you can right click on the image,select properties and cut and paste the URL http://www.geocities.com/wrpinkley/rout.GIF into a new explorer window.
Not a solution but at least a workaround!
Cheers
Andy
Anonymous
Member
- Joined
- Apr 17, 2004
- Messages
- 897
- Reaction score
- 6
- Country
-
Rout
IMHO, the Russian unit can rout away.
Surrendering doesn't come into play. A20.21 say (first, edition, but I don't think this has changed) that a unit will become a prisoner only if "ADJACENT to Known, Good Order, armed enemy Infantry/Cavalry". It goes on to say "If the only adjacent enemy unit is a vehicle, the broken unit must rout away." So the unit must rout away.
Since surrendering is NA, the ordinary rout requirements come into play. The unit can Low Crawl to M5 (not ADJACENT to an enemy, no closer to an enemy), or it can rout thru M5 (risking Interdiction) into M4.
I think the key is: the tank forces the broken unit to rout, but cannot accept a surrender, so the unit routs normally (if possible, which it is in your example).
IMHO, the Russian unit can rout away.
Surrendering doesn't come into play. A20.21 say (first, edition, but I don't think this has changed) that a unit will become a prisoner only if "ADJACENT to Known, Good Order, armed enemy Infantry/Cavalry". It goes on to say "If the only adjacent enemy unit is a vehicle, the broken unit must rout away." So the unit must rout away.
Since surrendering is NA, the ordinary rout requirements come into play. The unit can Low Crawl to M5 (not ADJACENT to an enemy, no closer to an enemy), or it can rout thru M5 (risking Interdiction) into M4.
I think the key is: the tank forces the broken unit to rout, but cannot accept a surrender, so the unit routs normally (if possible, which it is in your example).
G
Guest
Guest
I think I fixed the picture problem (web page naming conflict on Geocities)....please let me know if anyone still has problems viewing it.
Regards,
Regards,
Hubbs5
Member
Sorry Randy,
I still don't see the picture, just a little red X.
I still don't see the picture, just a little red X.
sgtono
Member
Looking at the picture I would have to agree with Greg S. 's conclusion.