Rate the scenario or CG above you.

[Honza]

A few rules: give the scenario or CG above you a rating out of 10 (i.e. 6/10 for slightly better than average). If you don't know the scenario you can check the Scenario Archive http://www.aslscenarioarchive.com/index.php?login=1
If you have not played the scenario give it a rating of how interesting it looks and how much you would like to play it. Give us a reason for your rating.

Then suggest the next scenario or CG for the next person to rate.

Here is the first choice. KGP CG I - Clash At Stoumont.

 

[Vinnie]

7/10. Interesting enough but the original drafting msdevit very hard for the attackers while the revision made it almost certain the defenders will be pushed off the map. Then you have a slow build up and a one sided conflict.

FT259 Alcazar!

 

[Honza]

Looks like a medium tourney scenario. Not really familiar with this one and it does not grab my interest. 4/10.

G33 The Awakening Of Spring.

 

[thedrake]

Looks like a medium tourney scenario. Not really familiar with this one and it does not grab my interest. 4/10.

G33 The Awakening Of Spring.

Heavy metal slugfest, seems difficult for the Germans.

SP166 Blue Jacket Attack

 

[Cpl Uhl]

Oh, I like this thread idea! Haven't played/seen Sp166 so will wait for later entry.

 

[Honza]

SP166 Blue Jacket Attack

Small PTO scenario. No Guns or AFV as far as I can tell from the archive. A bit too small for my liking. My interest to play it is 3/10.

My choice - Le Manoir (2nd edition) ASL13.

 

[Honza]

Heavy metal slugfest, seems difficult for the Germans.

Got a rating for it out of 10?

 

[thedrake]

Have not played it but 7/10 because it is late-war, heavy tanks and AT, and takes place in Hungary in 1945.

 

[Roy]

G33 The Awakening Of Spring.

Played it, liked it. Not every day you get the chance to use the Russian 100L AT gun. My German opponent rode his tanks in and I made a mess of them.

6/10

A38 North Bank

 

[Roy]

My choice - Le Manoir (2nd edition) ASL13.

I like Le Manoir
7/10

77 LeHerisson

 

[Michael R]

Played Le Herrisson several times. The German AFV are fickle and fragile. The French have a good fall back possibility. I rate it 6/10.

1 Fighting Withdrawal

 

[Binchois]

ASL1 Fighting Withdrawal: 9/10

Now that you mention it, I think I am suffering from withdrawal not having played Fighting Withdrawal lately!

Possibly the most played ASL scenario (though perhaps not as much as The Guards Counterattack), I have played it at least a dozen times. I love Finns, and for a very stripped-down and dirty Infantry game, I find there's a lot of variety to be had between playings.

Though it is pretty well balanced, I must say, the Finns seem to win most of the time in my games. Then perhaps I don't know how to play as the Russians!

Next Up: AP62: Shouting into the Storm

P.S. Great thread idea, Honza!!

 

[Honza]

Shouting Into The Storm is on my to play list. Looks very interesting and I have heard it is tense and fun. 8/10.

Clearing The Breskens Pocket - by Coastal Fortress SL220

 

[Vinnie]

Shouting Into The Storm is on my to play list. Looks very interesting and I have heard it is tense and fun. 8/10.

Clearing The Breskens Pocket - by Coastal Fortress SL220

2/10. The size disguise the fact that this is a slow tedious scenario idea where too large forces mean tgere is little to no room for manoeuvre.

ABTF3 six pound prize.

 

[Honza]

Do you mean SP115 The Five Pound Prize? (ABTF3 is "Late For Mass")

It looks like a decent tourney scenario which has got a good reputation. 6/10.

U28 Sowchos 79.

 

[Vinnie]

ABTF 4 First threat. I misremebered.

 

[Honza]

ABTF 4 First threat. I misremebered.

A Historical tourney scenario. Don't know it. Appeal = 4/10

U28 Sowchos 79

 

[asloser]

A Historical tourney scenario. Don't know it. Appeal = 4/10

U28 Sowchos 79

10/10.

A real classic, I would play this again anytime.

CH18 Raging Furnace

 

[Honza]

Ahhh...a Klautky special. With all the interesting SSR. I haven't played it but would love to. It is a novelty in the ASL world. 9/10.

ASL159 White Tigers 2nd edition.

 

[Eagle4ty]

ASL1 Fighting Withdrawal: 9/10

Now that you mention it, I think I am suffering from withdrawal not having played Fighting Withdrawal lately!

Possibly the most played ASL scenario (though perhaps not as much as The Guards Counterattack), I have played it at least a dozen times. I love Finns, and for a very stripped-down and dirty Infantry game, I find there's a lot of variety to be had between playings.

Though it is pretty well balanced, I must say, the Finns seem to win most of the time in my games. Then perhaps I don't know how to play as the Russians!

Next Up: AP62: Shouting into the Storm

P.S. Great thread idea, Honza!!

AP62: Shouting into the Storm?
10 of 10, A great must play scenario! With the force selection options, will offer a different look most of the time as well.

AP55 The Generalissimo's Own ?