Question on HG2-2

[jwb3]

Well, we have been using this special rule for years without issue.

My question is, how many scenarios say "Scenario Defender" on them. I believe this would something significantly less than 1% of all published scenarios.

The only time a scenario needs to mention "Scenario Defender" is when it breaks the established rules for same. Unless that type of scenario is significantly more than 1% of all published scenarios, I think your statistic might be a bit... statistically meaningless?

If one side sets up as if the other enters from offboard, the condition for "Scenario Defender" per the index is now met, AND allows the concealment setup per A12.12.
I dont know, but I believe our SBR is simple, short and makes the point.

I might suggest using:
"SS2: The Italians setup as if the Greeks enter from offmap (A12.12, C6.41)."

Or are there more considerations than '?' and BS?


John