Yes. Want.
Incidentally, could you include the BFP2 counters in the reprint and make it $20?
Thirded!
What might be an idea is to put the reprint on hold and re-poll when you are near to printing counters for your next product. There would be a number of advantages:
1. Players would have had time to consider the "white core" issue. Most of the initial excitement will have died down and only those really interested will respond. More people will have had a chance to appreciate B&J which might generate more firm sales. Or not.
2. A bigger print run might get you some discount.
3. You could then offer the BFP 2 (Op Cobra), BFP 3 (B&J) and next product counters as one "Super Counter" pack. (Marketing to counter sluts like me)
4. You would have had a chance for "mature consideration" of the issue and the logistics.
Whatever you decide, don't screw yourselves (financially or emotionally) and don't allow it to bugger up too much your next product.