Map Design Suggestions

Menschenfresser

The Amazing Rando
Joined
Oct 9, 2002
Messages
1,649
Reaction score
1
Location
Hell's Kitchen
Hi guys,
I've read the few articles on map design that I can find.

However, for two nights in a row, I started to design a map of finland....I've collected a lot of info, and even have a map nearly the same time period. But as I begin, I've run into problems.

First, I am not sure of the size per hex I should shoot for. I started making a 10k per hex map, as the legend of my original has that as it's smallest measurement. I began outlining it with a border or water where appropriate. Went fine, except I ran out of room with Opart limits. So I started again with Opart300. Live and learn.

I went down the western border of finland and then did the coast. Was pretty satisfied until I got to the actual area where most of the Winter War was fought, and I realized.....Oh crap. With 10k per hex, the pennisula will be too small.

I have most of the previous Winter War scenarios. None model all of the front...at least those that I can open. I am starting to think there is a good reason for this. Some of the war is so particular, it has to be modelled on a smaller scale. I'm at a loss of where to take it from here.

The battle on the pennisula is where the concentration of the armies lie, but the battles near the middle matter for supply reasons and shouldn't be left out of a major undertaking to portray this war. Problem seems to lie in the fact that other than in the south, this war had no continuous front as the Russians were confined to the roads.

If anyone has given this or something similar any thought, and might be able to provide some assistance, I'd be grateful. Finland is large and the actual site of battle is relatively small. Perhaps I could black out much of the map and include three or four main sites of battle. Don't know. Perhaps I just need to talk it out.
 

Dan Neely

Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2002
Messages
952
Reaction score
0
Location
Johnstown, PA, USA
Country
llUnited States
IF you want to keep the full map without having the russians go offroad to flank the finns you could put badlands in the interior of the forrests to make htem unsupplied, and inpentrable for motorized/mechanized forces.
 

General Staff

Member
Joined
Aug 7, 2002
Messages
1,018
Reaction score
2
Location
Dublin, Ireland
Country
llIreland
Originally posted by Menschenfresser
...I am starting to think there is a good reason for this. Some of the war is so particular, it has to be modelled on a smaller scale. I'm at a loss of where to take it from here.

If anyone has given this or something similar any thought, and might be able to provide some assistance, I'd be grateful. Finland is large and the actual site of battle is relatively small. Perhaps I could black out much of the map and include three or four main sites of battle. Don't know. Perhaps I just need to talk it out.
You might want to talk to Sheikh Yerbouti, something of an expert on all things Arctic I believe despite the name. Also a couple of scenarios to his credit and in my experience very kind and helpful.
 
Last edited:

Stauffenberg

Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2002
Messages
333
Reaction score
2
Location
Outremer
Country
llCanada
Also Ilkka Mutanen and his Decision in the North scenario which covers the entire front in 1941. His map is a beautiful piece of work.

I am pushing around behind the scenes to see if we can get a "Warfarehq Gold Scenario" section up and this scenario by Ilkka would be a cert for inclusion.

D.
 

Menschenfresser

The Amazing Rando
Joined
Oct 9, 2002
Messages
1,649
Reaction score
1
Location
Hell's Kitchen
Thanks guys....

I'll check out Decision in the North and see how that version of the map was attempted. Don't think I have that one.
 
Top