German 37L AT gun

[Jeffrey D Myers]

That's the problem with working with "Perry sez" collections: Perry's answers include both "here's what the rules say" answers, and "the rules are not 100% clear/foolproof, here's a ruling". But when not officially turned into errata, the latter have no effect on the rules themselves, and I can understand that some people insist on playing by the rules as written (and as amended by errata, of course).

Currently, MMP still issue errata from the 20th century: by printing them in the ASL Journal. I for one would not be sorry to see them move to a format where they released them somewhat faster, by posting them to their website or whatever. And, why not, make "Perry sez" into an official source of errata (which is a different thing: an erratum requires specific wording to change the rules - Perry's answers are typically way shorter than that).

I'm looking forward to playing FT 221 solo shortly, in which the Germans in 1945 will pick a 37L AT gun.... If I roll doubles, I'll consider listening to Perry....

 

[Robin Reeve]

There is no need for errata in the present case.

 

[STAVKA]

That's the problem with working with "Perry sez" collections: Perry's answers include both "here's what the rules say" answers, and "the rules are not 100% clear/foolproof, here's a ruling". But when not officially turned into errata, the latter have no effect on the rules themselves, and I can understand that some people insist on playing by the rules as written (and as amended by errata, of course).

Currently, MMP still issue errata from the 20th century: by printing them in the ASL Journal. I for one would not be sorry to see them move to a format where they released them somewhat faster, by posting them to their website or whatever. And, why not, make "Perry sez" into an official source of errata (which is a different thing: an erratum requires specific wording to change the rules - Perry's answers are typically way shorter than that).

That is great suggestions, now the errata updates are as slow as Perry slow-motion playing style, I mean - a bunch of 8-year-olds would cry out loud if Perry was nominated as the man to cut up the birthday cake.

 

[STAVKA]

There is no need for errata in the present case.

For you? or us all and if so, how did you reach that conclusion?

 

[Larry]

Because the wiki confirms commonsense that the projectile is not 37mm:

• Warhead diameter: 160 mm

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stielgranate_41

 

[Dagney]

Does the 37L mounted on the SPW 251/10 and 250/10 get the Steilgrenate 41?

 

[STAVKA]

Because the wiki confirms commonsense that the projectile is not 37mm:

• Warhead diameter: 160 mm

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stielgranate_41

Common sense we can agree upon. Although rules need to be corrected, players read the rules and play accordingly.

 

[STAVKA]

Does the 37L mounted on the SPW 251/10 and 250/10 get the Steilgrenate 41?

No, never.

 

[Mr Incredible]

Does the 37L mounted on the SPW 251/10 and 250/10 get the Steilgrenate 41?

Nope, just the 3.7cm PaK 35/36 ATG and 3.7cm FLaK 36 o. 37.

That's all I can see on the vehicle and ordnance listings.

 

[Mr Incredible]

Now with the TH, does it get the Case L mods?

It is not a LATW, so that suggests that it can claim Case L.

So the required DR to hit would be (including Case E/L without any other mods):

0 - 9
1 - 12
2 - 10
3 - 8
4 - 7
5 - 6
6 - 5
7 - 4
8 - 3
9 - 2

It could also conceivably claim Acquisition too? That would add another 1 or 2 to the above #s.

I think I have that correct.

Thoughts?

 

[klasmalmstrom]

That's the problem with working with "Perry sez" collections: Perry's answers include both "here's what the rules say" answers, and "the rules are not 100% clear/foolproof, here's a ruling". But when not officially turned into errata, the latter have no effect on the rules themselves, and I can understand that some people insist on playing by the rules as written (and as amended by errata, of course).

Nope, just the 3.7cm PaK 35/36 ATG and 3.7cm FLaK 36 o. 37.

That's all I can see on the vehicle and ordnance listings.

Axis Minor Vehicle Note 16 and Ordnance 24 also have them.