Scott Tortorice
Senior Member
Good editorial here:
Does CGI Ruin Movies?
Does Cameron realize that this isn't new technology? That audiences have seen motion capture before in movies such as Zemeckis' Beowulf and A Christmas Carol, two movies that underwhelmed audiences and critics with its motion capture tech? That Lucas attempted to wow audiences with this same gimmickry and ended up making the disappointing SW prequels?
Thinking along the same lines:
Does CGI Ruin Movies?
I recently saw Cameron hyping Avatar by enthusiastically pointing out that all the characters in his movie aren't animated but are real actors animated by motion capture! Woohoo! Then he went on to show his wired-up actors riding wire-framed creatures for the ultimate in realism.Today's big budget movies have the technology to create worlds and characters unlike anything we've ever seen before... but is that really a good thing? What if CGI just distracts from all the important things about moviemaking?
Does Cameron realize that this isn't new technology? That audiences have seen motion capture before in movies such as Zemeckis' Beowulf and A Christmas Carol, two movies that underwhelmed audiences and critics with its motion capture tech? That Lucas attempted to wow audiences with this same gimmickry and ended up making the disappointing SW prequels?
Thinking along the same lines:
More worryingly, CGI has given free rein to the worst, most-OCD elements of moviemakers' imaginations. Whereas, before, worldbuilding would have meant coming up with the strongest stories and performances in order to pull audiences in, now both of those seem to often take backseats to the spectacle of the spectacle itself (Think of this summer's Transformers: Revenge of The Fallen, which didn't appear to make sense, or again, the Star Wars prequels, where Lucas as a director was clearly more in love with the technology responsible for the worlds he was building than the actors and dialogue he was populating them with). That James Cameron has created languages, flora and fauna and hundreds of elements for Avatar's Pandora that we may not even really see in the finished product is, at once, both an impressive and incredibly frustrating feat: Good for him for being so dedicated, but without a good story, it'll be the most expensive window dressing for a store that no-one wants to shop at.