esprcorn
Member
Curious about a few things.... Is it unusual that this clear reprint from Dispatches was retitled? If I'm correct, reprints in official products usually keep the original name.
So it looks like J26 has been updated a bit with some changes to the OB and additional overlays. 140 from 3rd edition of Doomed Battalions seems a duplicate other than indicating the arrival of Air Support potentially on turn 3 on the turn track.
ROAR Data.
DB002 German 6 Polish 8
J26 German 25 Polish 15
140 German 1 Polish 6 (Despite no changes - the balance has swung!)
I guess the original seems the most balanced without enough plays to be sure. The newer official versions seem to be 26/21 if you add 'em up.
Any thoughts on these? Which is the best version? I still see DB002 Sochaczew come up on play lists even today. I imagine this is mostly due to people being unaware that J16/140 Round Two are the same, updated, scenario?
Thanks in advance for your thoughts...
So it looks like J26 has been updated a bit with some changes to the OB and additional overlays. 140 from 3rd edition of Doomed Battalions seems a duplicate other than indicating the arrival of Air Support potentially on turn 3 on the turn track.
ROAR Data.
DB002 German 6 Polish 8
J26 German 25 Polish 15
140 German 1 Polish 6 (Despite no changes - the balance has swung!)
I guess the original seems the most balanced without enough plays to be sure. The newer official versions seem to be 26/21 if you add 'em up.
Any thoughts on these? Which is the best version? I still see DB002 Sochaczew come up on play lists even today. I imagine this is mostly due to people being unaware that J16/140 Round Two are the same, updated, scenario?
Thanks in advance for your thoughts...