Of course, you mean T7.
- from T6 to V6
- from T6 to U6
Interesting point! A Dash does need to cross from one side of a road to the other. But intersections do complicate matters. I would say that if neither T7 nor U6 is OG (or in LOS) to the Firer, than it is a DASH across the NW-to-SE running road.T7 to U6 would not allow Dash IMHO because in this case you would not actually have to cross a road depiction.
That's my take as well. T7->U6 doesn't seem to cross a road IMO.T7 to V6 would allow Dash because you would have to cross the road depiction in any case.
T7 to U6 would not allow Dash IMHO because in this case you would not actually have to cross a road depiction.
But referring to the Q&A (possibly older, but I see no reason to disregard it), if neither T7 nor U6 was a road hex, than it would be a dash across the end of a road - which is legal according to the Q&A. So long as neither of these hexes is in LOS to the firer, than I think the same thing applies whether or not there is a road in those hexes. Or would you still disagree in this case?That's my take as well. T7->U6 doesn't seem to cross a road IMO.
This depends upon the position of the firer. The wall might interfere (making it not OG) or the hex might be out-of-LOS, so it's a moot point.t7 IS OPEN GROUND OR NOT?
To a certain extent, it doesn't matter. You can still declare a dash but will only get the benefit from firers to who it is not open ground.t7 IS OPEN GROUND OR NOT?
Kind of confusing as they're using a house rule for OBA as it looks as if it's Blue for Harrassing Fire (C1.72), but given the location of the FFE counter T7 is not OG to the firer.But referring to the Q&A (possibly older, but I see no reason to disregard it), if neither T7 nor U6 was a road hex, than it would be a dash across the end of a road - which is legal according to the Q&A. So long as neither of these hexes is in LOS to the firer, than I think the same thing applies whether or not there is a road in those hexes. Or would you still disagree in this case?
This depends upon the position of the firer. The wall might interfere (making it not OG) or the hex might be out-of-LOS, so it's a moot point.
BTW, all Russian fire appears that it would pass through FFE LOS hindrances. Is this hindrance enough to cancel "Open Ground" to these oh-so-dashing German men? I think so.
Sorry to bump this when the interested parties have moved on but I am interested in a bit more as I think Binchois has the better of the argument and don't see a resolution (an absurd expectation for an ASL rulebook discussion, but hey, that's me).That's my take as well. T7->U6 doesn't seem to cross a road IMO.