Bridge LOS/LOF B6.2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
:?: Does a unit under a bridge counter have a LOS/LOF to a unit on the road adjacent to and accessing the bridge counter? (i.e. ASL RB page B5 6.2 example ... a unit under the bridge in CC5 attacking a unit in DD5.)
Rob MacDonald
Today, 09:52 #2
CHERDE
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: The Ruhr
Posts: 1 YES a LOS exists.
ASLRB B 6.2 2nd sentence
I refer to this short thread and want to ask following questions:
a)LOS from 12E10 to unit IN 12E9 (EX pg B18 ASLRB)- Does +1 Hindrance from the bridge apply?
I would say YES because of ASLRB B 6.2 3rd sentence
and because of annual 96, Debriefing B 6.2
Also there is a comparable situation regarding smoke in annual 96, Debriefing A 24.4 and in Journal#1 pg. 7/8 "Smoke gets in your eyes".
b) DFF from unit IN 12F8 to moving unit IN 12E9 - Does FFMO apply?
I would say NO, because its Open Ground, B 19.3. and there is no Hindrance BETWEEN firer and target, A 6.7
c)LOS from unit IN 13J5 to unit IN 13L6 (EX pg B4 ASLRB)- Does +1 Hindrance from the bridge apply?
I would say NO, because both, firer AND target, are beneath the level of the bridge, ASLRB B 6.2 3rd sentence .
d)LOS from unit IN 13J5 to unit IN 13L6 BUT there is no elevated road and the bridge is at ground level (EX pg B4 ASLRB)- Does +1 Hindrance from the bridge apply?
I would say NO, because both, firer AND target, are beneath the level of the bridge, ASLRB B 6.2 3rd sentence = same answer as c)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
:?: Does a unit under a bridge counter have a LOS/LOF to a unit on the road adjacent to and accessing the bridge counter? (i.e. ASL RB page B5 6.2 example ... a unit under the bridge in CC5 attacking a unit in DD5.)
Rob MacDonald
Today, 09:52 #2
CHERDE
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: The Ruhr
Posts: 1 YES a LOS exists.
ASLRB B 6.2 2nd sentence
I refer to this short thread and want to ask following questions:
a)LOS from 12E10 to unit IN 12E9 (EX pg B18 ASLRB)- Does +1 Hindrance from the bridge apply?
I would say YES because of ASLRB B 6.2 3rd sentence
and because of annual 96, Debriefing B 6.2
Also there is a comparable situation regarding smoke in annual 96, Debriefing A 24.4 and in Journal#1 pg. 7/8 "Smoke gets in your eyes".
b) DFF from unit IN 12F8 to moving unit IN 12E9 - Does FFMO apply?
I would say NO, because its Open Ground, B 19.3. and there is no Hindrance BETWEEN firer and target, A 6.7
c)LOS from unit IN 13J5 to unit IN 13L6 (EX pg B4 ASLRB)- Does +1 Hindrance from the bridge apply?
I would say NO, because both, firer AND target, are beneath the level of the bridge, ASLRB B 6.2 3rd sentence .
d)LOS from unit IN 13J5 to unit IN 13L6 BUT there is no elevated road and the bridge is at ground level (EX pg B4 ASLRB)- Does +1 Hindrance from the bridge apply?
I would say NO, because both, firer AND target, are beneath the level of the bridge, ASLRB B 6.2 3rd sentence = same answer as c)