Bounding First Fire Blackpool 2018 AAR

Toby Pilling

Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Messages
194
Reaction score
212
Location
Didcot
Country
llUnited Kingdom
A week has passed and I’ve had time to compose my thoughts, so decided to write up a bit of a report on the first Bounding First Fire tournament that was recently held in Blackpool.

Let me say at the outset that I thought it was superb: Martin and Simon were excellent hosts and there were surprisingly few hiccups, given this was their first experience of tournament organisation.

What made the tournament unique in my eyes, was that each of the five rounds featured a brand new, unpublished scenario from Bounding Fire Productions. Though one could bid for a side, the balance on offer was minimal (upgrading a 7-0 leader to an 8-0, for example), so one often ended up pretty much dicing for sides – only once did my opponent and I each bid for different sides, the rest of the time was a dice-off (two I won, two I lost).

Of course, this means that one is pretty much at the mercy of BFP and the tournament directors (who also tested them in advance) to provide balanced fare, which thankfully they excelled at.

The other unusual thing about the tournament was that it had a sort of World Cup type organisation, in that players had to qualify from groups in order to progress to the semi-final stage. Unlike the World Cup though, the groups weren’t seeded, so there was a certain inevitability about proceedings when Mark Blackmore and I were not only drawn in the same ‘group of death’, but were scheduled to play in the first round, thus pretty much knocking one of us out straight away. As we were the two clear favourites in the whole tournament, this was somewhat odd - in the future I suppose groups could be seeded after all, if it was deemed desirable to do so.

Anyway, as to be expected, my first game was indeed the hardest test of skill, as Mark is a great, aggressive player who can really press the attack, especially when he has elite infantry, scornful of the risks he takes with their cardboard lives. As no-one else has yet seen the scenarios we played at the tournament, it seems pointless to describe the action in detail – it was an infantry-only affair where I was defending with Norwegians against Gebirgsjäger. I ended up hunkering down in a factory and Mark needed to roll a 7 or less to win the scenario in the last close combat – he rolled an 8.

Interestingly, though the first scenario was a fairly ‘standard’ one, the next three were all very unusual, with multiple defensive options and often a lack of skulking possibilities. I defended in two of these and attacked in one and found them very much brain teasers – one featuring Italian defenders had all of us constructing completely different plans. Suffice to say that, though there was the odd scare, I progressed to the final where I met David Blackwood and we played a 1940 scenario called ‘Senagalese in Souain’, which was depicted in diorama form on the tournament trophy – a brilliant idea. This is a cracking scenario that I think might feature in future tournaments, and has a German combined arms force attacking a French reinforced company in a village. We both wanted the attackers and I won the roll-off, so unleashed a bit of a Blitzkrieg which steamrollered through the gallant Poilus, ending their resistance around turn 4 (of 7). Both main prizes were valuable modules and I picked up Objective Schmidt, which I was very pleased with.

The great thing about this tournament is that one cannot prepare for it – each round, one is presented with a new and novel tactical situation to examine, bid for sides and begin playing, completely from scratch. It requires a different skill set from traditional tournaments and truly tests a player’s abilities, pushing them out of their comfort zone.

Also, those with constricted spare time in real life don’t have to worry about competing at a disadvantage because they weren’t able to try some scenarios on the tournament list in advance - one can pretty much just turn up and play. I just hope Martin and Simon can maintain the format and get more excellent scenarios from BFP in the future.

So, I can win a tournament without preparing in advance. Who knew, eh?
 
Last edited:

JoeArthur

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2016
Messages
1,108
Reaction score
1,067
Location
Broadstairs
Country
llUnited Kingdom
Those prizes that Martin and Simon bought tempted you back to tournys Toby? :D

That is the issue with this format - everyone's entry fee goes to you, Craig or Mark. Well, more accurately according to the website £185 of £409. I told Martin about the system in Villeneuve D'Ascq, the French tournament where everyone walks away with a prize..........from memory Martin said "none of that socialist crap here".

Might see you there next year. Glad to see that you enjoyed the tourny and hope that things are good.............
 

Martin Mayers

Elder Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
4,571
Reaction score
1,991
Location
The Gulag
First name
Gulagwanker
Country
llUkraine
Those prizes that Martin and Simon bought tempted you back to tournys Toby? :D

That is the issue with this format - everyone's entry fee goes to you, Craig or Mark. Well, more accurately according to the website £185 of £409. I told Martin about the system in Villeneuve D'Ascq, the French tournament where everyone walks away with a prize..........from memory Martin said "none of that socialist crap here".

Might see you there next year. Glad to see that you enjoyed the tourny and hope that things are good.............
Hang about. Previous winners of the Blackpool tournament = Simon Staniforth, Ian Morris, Gerard Burton, Georges Tournemire to name but a few. I myself have won a number of the tournaments (top group a couple of times down at Double One, main prize at Intensive Fire for my 9-0 result which is now written in the annals of ASL history and for the record included a defeat of Craig). Georges, Simon, Ian, and Gerard all won the same tournament that Craig and Mark, took part in. It's a bit dismissive to suggest that Craig, Mark or even Toby are auto-shoe ins for main prizes.

There were nine prizes handed out of which Toby won one (a diarama plus a BF module kindly provided by the BF guys). Mark won two prizes. David Blackwood, the runner up, won over £150 of Bounding Fire gear and was absolutely stoked. The prizes for the open tournament (Final Crisis in Blackpool) were particularly pleasing to the eye. Joe Leoce, the designer, and prize provider, really worked some magic on those. The Broken Ground Counters were also especially well received. And the Battleschool dice were a really nice touch for the winner of each minis round (we'd have liked to have given out more....but kept them for next year).

So no. I refute the idea that the entry fee went to Toby. A custom designed, one of a kind, diarama went to Toby to reward the fact that he was the best player there. That's tournaments man. I don't think the playing field could have been made any more level by way of the format. We actively tried to make it so that the best players would be less likely to sweep in and scoop the best prize.......my entire modus operandi was to find out just how good these really good players such as Toby and Mark are. And, you know what, they're bloody good and certainly proved me wrong!

We may well have the spare cash next year to hand out a small gift. Something I'm actively considering. But it won't be a prize. I'd actually favour one of the custom diaramas for winner AND runner up. Mebbe even a prize for group winners.
 

JoeArthur

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2016
Messages
1,108
Reaction score
1,067
Location
Broadstairs
Country
llUnited Kingdom
Hello Martin,

Good to hear from you. Just one point - you are not comparing like with like. You have turned this into a blind tournament which I suspect will favour the better players. Time will tell on that one. You have also removed yourself and Simon from the field because you are very kindly running the tournament for everyone.

As for the rest - it's your tournament, your rules :)
 

Vinnie

See Dummies in the index
Joined
Feb 9, 2005
Messages
17,445
Reaction score
3,392
Location
Aberdeen , Scotland
Country
llUnited Kingdom
I don't think any who attended thought this was a method to get a great prize into a particular players hands! That thought needs to be quashed right away!
The prizes were magnificent with the diorama and the "final crisis" being the best! To be honest, if I'd won (ha!) I had no interest in the BFP packs, the dice or the Broken Ground counters as I have all of those already. I not decrying them, it's a wonderful gesture from the suppliers.

The diorama and Japanese mortar setting were just tgat little bit special. You can't buy them.
 

Martin Mayers

Elder Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
4,571
Reaction score
1,991
Location
The Gulag
First name
Gulagwanker
Country
llUkraine
Hello Martin,

Good to hear from you. Just one point - you are not comparing like with like. You have turned this into a blind tournament which I suspect will favour the better players. Time will tell on that one. You have also removed yourself and Simon from the field because you are very kindly running the tournament for everyone.

As for the rest - it's your tournament, your rules :)
Toby beat Dave Blackwood in the final. Dave is 189th on the Crusader ladder out of 317. Will Binns who Dave beat in the semi final is 48th. Not sure who Dave beat in the rounds but he won three games against players I suspect were higher up the ladder than he.

I'm not convinced the evidence is backing up your claim of this suiting the better players.

Really though. Do people really want a complete lack of any competitiveness at these events? If everyone who attended comes back and says they'd like us to invest the money on attendance prizes for everyone and the winner gets a pat on the back, their attendance badge, and a £10 gift voucher then I'm fine with that.
 
Last edited:

Martin Mayers

Elder Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2008
Messages
4,571
Reaction score
1,991
Location
The Gulag
First name
Gulagwanker
Country
llUkraine
I don't think any who attended thought this was a method to get a great prize into a particular players hands! That thought needs to be quashed right away!
The prizes were magnificent with the diorama and the "final crisis" being the best! To be honest, if I'd won (ha!) I had no interest in the BFP packs, the dice or the Broken Ground counters as I have all of those already. I not decrying them, it's a wonderful gesture from the suppliers.

The diorama and Japanese mortar setting were just tgat little bit special. You can't buy them.
The entire debate has me laughing a little inside. I remember saying to my co pilot Simon on numerous occasions "this will find out how good those buggers who win these tournaments are". And Toby comes along just to shove my words down my throat. All credit to him.
 
Top