Are any of these CH products actually in print?

Pitman

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
14,005
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Columbus, OH
Country
llUnited States
I've completed my Critical Hit spreadsheet, part of which involves confirming that alleged Critical Hit products actually exist, because CH has a habit of suggesting they do when they do not...yet.

I've been able to confirm most items by finding them for sale on retail sites or by finding ASLers who have discussed owning them. However, I have not been able to confirm the physical existence in print of the below products.

If you have a copy of any of the below products, can you confirm for me that they currently physically exist? Thanks very much.

Bye Bye Baby Bye Bye: Bulge
Cambrai 2: Black Friday Fontaine
Cambrai 3: A Panorama of Hell Bourlon
CH Annual 5
CWASL GEO Module 1
CWASL GEO Module 2
CWASL GEO Module 3
The Devil's Vineyard: Heraklion 1941
Drive to the Volga 3: Stalingrad Sud 1
Drive to the Volga 4: Stalingrad Sud 2
Freedom's Price: Hungary 1
Freedom's Price: Hungary 2
Graebner's Charge: Arnhem 1944
GWASL 5: Hapsburg Ambitions/Austria-Hungary
GWASL 6: Blood on the Isonzo/Italy
GWASL 7: Soldiers of the Sultan
GWASL 8: Gallipoli and Beyond/Aussies/Anzac
GWASL 9: Bulgarian Summer/Bulgaria
GWASL 10: Slavic Warriors/Serbia
GWASL 11: Balkan Aspirations/Romania
GWASL 12: With the British in Palestine
GWASL 13: German East Africa
GWASL 14: Yster Stand/Belgium
Kaunas Offensive: Bagration 1944
Leningrad 1: Brandenburger Bridgehead
Leningrad 2: Thunder on the Luga
Siberian Onslaught: The Dead of Winter
Sisu 1: Freedom's Price, 39-40
Valley of Tears: Battles for the Golan Heights
 

Gunner Scott

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
13,137
Reaction score
1,791
Location
Chicago, IL
Country
llUnited States
I can confirm:
Leningrad 1: Brandenburger Bridgehead
Leningrad 2: Thunder on the Luga

Both of these have been published here are some pics.
 

Attachments

Gunner Scott

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
13,137
Reaction score
1,791
Location
Chicago, IL
Country
llUnited States
I do have Kaunas Offensive: Bagration 1944 but no pics, if you want pics let me know and I'll take them. As an aside, boy thats alot of dead trees for collectors lol.
 

Pitman

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
14,005
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Columbus, OH
Country
llUnited States
If you are willing to share pics, that would be great. Are you saying I can use the Leningrad pics on the website?
 

Gunner Scott

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
13,137
Reaction score
1,791
Location
Chicago, IL
Country
llUnited States
Here is Kaunas Offensive: Bagration 1944; I would not recommend buying this because the counter sheets are of different colors, looks RT just shoved any old counter sheet into this one. Also, One scenario uses both maps IE the Nord Map pictured below and a Sud map which I do not have. After the discount, the module did cost me a grand total of 60 odd bucks. Still too expensive for the content you do receive. Have not looked at everything closely but I am betting there are the usual edit errors and more. Would not be surprised. Unfortunately I am a sucker for most things East front but the lack of substance for this particular item turned me off to buying his Sud map version.
 

Attachments

Danno

Ost Front Fanatic
Joined
Mar 12, 2005
Messages
1,316
Reaction score
562
Location
Land of OZ
Country
llUnited States
Mark,

The following are in print:

CH Annual 5
The Devil's Vineyard: Heraklion 1941
GWASL 5: Hapsburg Ambitions/Austria-Hungary
GWASL 6: Blood on the Isonzo/Italy
GWASL 7: Soldiers of the Sultan
GWASL 8: Gallipoli and Beyond/Aussies/Anzac
Valley of Tears: Battles for the Golan Heights
In addition to what Scott has identified.

I recommend you check Scenario Archive as some are posted there with details about content. Including the three Scott has and Annual 5, Devil's Vineyard and Valley of Tears.

Danno
 

Pitman

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
14,005
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Columbus, OH
Country
llUnited States
Mark,

The following are in print:

CH Annual 5
The Devil's Vineyard: Heraklion 1941
GWASL 5: Hapsburg Ambitions/Austria-Hungary
GWASL 6: Blood on the Isonzo/Italy
GWASL 7: Soldiers of the Sultan
GWASL 8: Gallipoli and Beyond/Aussies/Anzac
Valley of Tears: Battles for the Golan Heights
In addition to what Scott has identified.

I recommend you check Scenario Archive as some are posted there with details about content. Including the three Scott has and Annual 5, Devil's Vineyard and Valley of Tears.

Danno
Dan, you have seen those items yourself? I am concerned about relying on the Scenario Archive and just assuming all the items there are in print.
 

Pitman

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
14,005
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Columbus, OH
Country
llUnited States
Here is Kaunas Offensive: Bagration 1944; I would not recommend buying this because the counter sheets are of different colors, looks RT just shoved any old counter sheet into this one. Also, One scenario uses both maps IE the Nord Map pictured below and a Sud map which I do not have. After the discount, the module did cost me a grand total of 60 odd bucks. Still too expensive for the content you do receive. Have not looked at everything closely but I am betting there are the usual edit errors and more. Would not be surprised. Unfortunately I am a sucker for most things East front but the lack of substance for this particular item turned me off to buying his Sud map version.
Thanks, Scott.
 

Pitman

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
14,005
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Columbus, OH
Country
llUnited States
Here is Kaunas Offensive: Bagration 1944; I would not recommend buying this because the counter sheets are of different colors, looks RT just shoved any old counter sheet into this one. Also, One scenario uses both maps IE the Nord Map pictured below and a Sud map which I do not have. After the discount, the module did cost me a grand total of 60 odd bucks. Still too expensive for the content you do receive. Have not looked at everything closely but I am betting there are the usual edit errors and more. Would not be surprised. Unfortunately I am a sucker for most things East front but the lack of substance for this particular item turned me off to buying his Sud map version.
Scott, that does not look like Kaunas Offensive, it looks like Thunder at Melikhovo.
 

Danno

Ost Front Fanatic
Joined
Mar 12, 2005
Messages
1,316
Reaction score
562
Location
Land of OZ
Country
llUnited States
Dan, you have seen those items yourself? I am concerned about relying on the Scenario Archive and just assuming all the items there are in print.
Yes. I have seen those items. SA will have info on the scenarios and is useful for checking if they have been published before.
 

Whiskers1123

Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2012
Messages
386
Reaction score
158
Location
Arizona
Country
llUnited States
"If you have a copy of any of the below products, can you confirm for me that they currently physically exist? Thanks very much."

Bye Bye Baby Bye Bye: Bulge - This is out, I have a copy
GWASL Cambrai 2: Black Friday Fontaine - This has not shipped yet
GWASL Cambrai 3: A Panorama of Hell Bourlon - This has not shipped yet
CH Annual 5 - This is out, I have a copy
CWASL GEO Module 1 - This is out, I have a copy
CWASL GEO Module 2 - This is out, I have a copy
CWASL GEO Module 3 - This is out, I have a copy
The Devil's Vineyard: Heraklion 1941 - This is out, I have a copy
Drive to the Volga 3: Stalingrad Sud 1 - This has not shipped yet
Drive to the Volga 4: Stalingrad Sud 2 - This has not shipped yet
Freedom's Price: Hungary 1 - This has not shipped yet. Soon
Freedom's Price: Hungary 2 - This has not shipped yet. Soon
Graebner's Charge: Arnhem 1944 - This is out, I have a copy
GWASL 5: Hapsburg Ambitions/Austria-Hungary - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 6: Blood on the Isonzo/Italy - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 7: Soldiers of the Sultan - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 8: Gallipoli and Beyond/Aussies/Anzac - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 9: Bulgarian Summer/Bulgaria - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 10: Slavic Warriors/Serbia - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 11: Balkan Aspirations/Romania - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 12: With the British in Palestine - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 13: German East Africa - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 14: Yster Stand/Belgium - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 15: Vimy Ridge And Beyond - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 16: Rising Sun 1914 - This has not shipped yet
Kaunas Offensive: Bagration 1944 - This is out, I have a copy
Leningrad 1: Brandenburger Bridgehead - This is out, I have a copy
Leningrad 2: Thunder on the Luga - This is out, I have a copy
Siberian Onslaught: The Dead of Winter - This has not shipped yet. Any day.
Sisu 1: Freedom's Price, 39-40 - This is out, I have a copy
Valley of Tears: Battles for the Golan Height - This is out, I have a copy

I don't know why I am helping you but this is the status of those items as of today. You can find out about this stuff from his weekly news letter. If you don't get it he posts it on his web site in the Forum area every week.

Ray
 

cathmor01

Recruit
Joined
Jun 28, 2014
Messages
13
Reaction score
10
Location
Vancouver, WA
First name
Bryan
Country
llUnited States
Mark,

I can confirm that Bye Bye Baby 1: Bulge is a an actual product. From info gathered from your site, it appears to be a kind-of reprint of Euro Pack 2 / Bulge Pack 1.

Contents:
6 18" x 12.5" Winterized "geoboards" (B1-B6)
16 Scenarios (Bulge 19 #1-16) (the names of several match Euro Pack 2 names, though they've been adapted to play on the included maps.)
1 SSR sheet for entire pack
3 Full counter sheets and 3 half counter sheets (though they may have just been thrown in as a 1 week only promotion)


113961139711398113991140011401


Thanks again for all your hard work.

Bryan Richert
 
Last edited:

Pitman

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
14,005
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Columbus, OH
Country
llUnited States
"If you have a copy of any of the below products, can you confirm for me that they currently physically exist? Thanks very much."

Bye Bye Baby Bye Bye: Bulge - This is out, I have a copy
GWASL Cambrai 2: Black Friday Fontaine - This has not shipped yet
GWASL Cambrai 3: A Panorama of Hell Bourlon - This has not shipped yet
CH Annual 5 - This is out, I have a copy
CWASL GEO Module 1 - This is out, I have a copy
CWASL GEO Module 2 - This is out, I have a copy
CWASL GEO Module 3 - This is out, I have a copy
The Devil's Vineyard: Heraklion 1941 - This is out, I have a copy
Drive to the Volga 3: Stalingrad Sud 1 - This has not shipped yet
Drive to the Volga 4: Stalingrad Sud 2 - This has not shipped yet
Freedom's Price: Hungary 1 - This has not shipped yet. Soon
Freedom's Price: Hungary 2 - This has not shipped yet. Soon
Graebner's Charge: Arnhem 1944 - This is out, I have a copy
GWASL 5: Hapsburg Ambitions/Austria-Hungary - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 6: Blood on the Isonzo/Italy - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 7: Soldiers of the Sultan - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 8: Gallipoli and Beyond/Aussies/Anzac - This is out, I have a scan
GWASL 9: Bulgarian Summer/Bulgaria - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 10: Slavic Warriors/Serbia - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 11: Balkan Aspirations/Romania - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 12: With the British in Palestine - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 13: German East Africa - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 14: Yster Stand/Belgium - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 15: Vimy Ridge And Beyond - This has not shipped yet
GWASL 16: Rising Sun 1914 - This has not shipped yet
Kaunas Offensive: Bagration 1944 - This is out, I have a copy
Leningrad 1: Brandenburger Bridgehead - This is out, I have a copy
Leningrad 2: Thunder on the Luga - This is out, I have a copy
Siberian Onslaught: The Dead of Winter - This has not shipped yet. Any day.
Sisu 1: Freedom's Price, 39-40 - This is out, I have a copy
Valley of Tears: Battles for the Golan Height - This is out, I have a copy

I don't know why I am helping you but this is the status of those items as of today. You can find out about this stuff from his weekly news letter. If you don't get it he posts it on his web site in the Forum area every week.

Ray
Ray, thank you for providing this info!
 

Pitman

Elder Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2003
Messages
14,005
Reaction score
1,920
Location
Columbus, OH
Country
llUnited States
Mark,

I can confirm that Bye Bye Baby 1: Bulge is a an actual product. From info gathered from your site, it appears to be a kind-of reprint of Euro Pack 2 / Bulge Pack 1.

Contents:
6 18" x 12.5" Winterized "geoboards" (B1-B6)
20 Scenarios (Bulge #1-20) (the names of several match Euro Pack 2 names, though they've been adapted to play on the included maps.
1 SSR sheet for entire pack
3 Full counter sheets and 3 half counter sheets (though they may have just been thrown in as a 1 week only promotion)


View attachment 11396View attachment 11397View attachment 11398View attachment 11399View attachment 11400View attachment 11401


Thanks again for all your hard work.

Bryan Richert
Bryan, thank you very much!
 
Top