Jon
Senior Member
> A12.14 says "A concealed unit's '?' is also lost immediately if it does any
> of the following in LOS of a Good Order enemy ground unit within 16 hexes
> (such potential LOS checks are free and require no attack or penalty for a
> blocked LOS):"
>
> The wording is such that "?" loss occurs if there exists a LOS. Who is
> responsible for determining if LOS exists, the player performing the "?"
> loss activity, the opponent or both?
While both players may be responsible for determining LOS, the player seeking to deny concealment gain/retention is responsible for making such an LOS check.
>
> If an opponent declines to check LOS, may the player performing the "?" loss
> activity take a free LOS check to his opponent's unconcealed unit(s) to
> determine if in fact a LOS exists and as such his unit will lose Concealment
> from performing its action?
>
No.
....Perry
MMP
> of the following in LOS of a Good Order enemy ground unit within 16 hexes
> (such potential LOS checks are free and require no attack or penalty for a
> blocked LOS):"
>
> The wording is such that "?" loss occurs if there exists a LOS. Who is
> responsible for determining if LOS exists, the player performing the "?"
> loss activity, the opponent or both?
While both players may be responsible for determining LOS, the player seeking to deny concealment gain/retention is responsible for making such an LOS check.
>
> If an opponent declines to check LOS, may the player performing the "?" loss
> activity take a free LOS check to his opponent's unconcealed unit(s) to
> determine if in fact a LOS exists and as such his unit will lose Concealment
> from performing its action?
>
No.
....Perry
MMP