Search results

  1. Ed Donoghue

    Sniper #s for Journal scenarios

    Is there a listing of SA #s for Journal scenarios?
  2. Ed Donoghue

    ROAR?

    I cannot Record a New Playing in ROAR. Been trying for a couple days. Anyone else having a problem?
  3. Ed Donoghue

    scenario vs Wire & Roadblocks

    I am starting a scenario as attacker vs defender using Roadblocks & Wire, so I need a couple clarifications, please. B24.76: states a GO Infantry unit in a hex containing a Roadblock hexside may remove it as HM w/successful Clearance DR.........., Sounds like Infantry can be in either hexside...
  4. Ed Donoghue

    CC & Building control

    My opponent has 1 MMC in a multi hex building. In the Advance phase I move a MMC into CC with that unit and advance another MMC into a different hex in the same building. CC is initiated with neither side winning, resulting in MEELE, and neither MMC in MEELE is Good Order. As I have a...
  5. Ed Donoghue

    canister & VBM

    If a vehicle is in VBM & wishes to fire Canister is the target vertex at the back of the 2 hex line?
  6. Ed Donoghue

    BtB1

    Is there any errata on BtB1, TAKING TAILVILLE, specifically the placement of rubble in non building hexes, such as woods, orchards & open ground hexes?
  7. Ed Donoghue

    Woods Road LOS

    In scenario KGP2, using the ST map, does a unit in woods road hex HH8 in the, during DFPh, have a clear LOS to a stationary unit in building hex BB11 or does woods road hex EE10 block LOS. Please ignore the VH Mist effect on LOS. Thank you.
  8. Ed Donoghue

    FT

    I think I understand A22.32 that FT's can never fire > 2 levels higher or lower, pretty simple. So a FT @ ground level, adjacent to a multi level building, can fire @ an adjacent target on the second floor @ long range. Can that same FT, 1 hex away from the multi hex building still fire @ a...
  9. Ed Donoghue

    AP103

    Thanks, good stuff here
  10. Ed Donoghue

    G30 MORGAN'S STAND

    Is there any errata on this scenario, specifically SSR3 regarding US reinforcements. It feels like something was left out. It is impossible to get reinforcements on turn 2 unless there is a -1 DRM somewhere, so why not hold off rolling for them until turn 3?
  11. Ed Donoghue

    Double reduction?

    A full squad is broken in the PFPh. Same squad is fired on again in the APh, resulting in a MC. DR of 12 results in a failed MC. A routed unit that fails another MC suffers casualty reduction and is reduced to a half squad. A MC DR of 12 also results in a casualty reduction. Is the half...
  12. Ed Donoghue

    SW in a Trench

    I find no rule against an emplaced SW being set up in a Trench. Will this SW receive a +2 DRM for emplacement and additional +s for Trench DRMs, or is this a 'pick one emplacement of Trench' situation?
  13. Ed Donoghue

    street fighting

    (1) is street fighting considered Defensive Fire (2) can a unit marked w/DFF initiate street fighting (a unit cannot Reaction Fire if already marked w/DFF Thank you
  14. Ed Donoghue

    PFs for Axis Minor

    1945 scenario - Axis Minor (Hungarian) - their OB includes a PSK, would their allotment of PFs be the same as 1945 Germans?
  15. Ed Donoghue

    motorcycle riders as targets

    D15.5 reads: "all fire vs a mounted motorcyclist is subject to a -1 To Hit DRM for ordnance or a -1 IFT FDRM for non-ordnance weapons. All ordnance hits vs motorcyclists are resolved on the IFT. However, as riders motorcyclists are not subject to FFMO/FFNAM and would be subject to vehicular To...
  16. Ed Donoghue

    Same results or RS on Infantry Type Fire?

    Two MMCs in 1 hex, 1 concealed & 1 unconcealed are fired on by an AFV MA w/Infantry Type Fire. The Th # on the concealed unit is 2 higher than the other one, no problem. Dice roll is snakes, improbable hit followed by a dr of 3. Does this result call for a RS or are both units effected the same?
  17. Ed Donoghue

    help on complicated to hit calculations

    It seems that my brain goes numb every time I try to reason out the other than nice simple TH DRMs. Please help me with this. It is the DFPh, & I have a NT, CE, AFV, in OG & in motion that wishes to fire @ a large stationary vehicle 5 hexes away in OG with no hinderances. My vehicle needs to...
  18. Ed Donoghue

    EXCESSIVE SPEED

    Am I correct in saying that only fully tracked vehicles car run at excessive speed and risk the potential breakdown, halftracks cannot.
  19. Ed Donoghue

    G8 RECON IN FORCE

    I am looking for somebody who has played this scenario as the Axis and won (or a US player who has lost). US player must take either (see errata) building 21J4 from the Germans or 21Z2 from the Italians and their CVP must be triple the Axis total. ROAR has this @ 51/51. I recently played as...
  20. Ed Donoghue

    AAR A SIMPLE SOLUTION WO23

    Recently completed this scenario with long time (like pre SL) friend/opponent Ken We diced for sides, I got Axis, a mixed bag of 2nd line & C MMCs (10/7), 4 leaders, one @ -1, 1 HMG, 4 LMGs & 6 ?s. The Big Red One sent 18 1st line MMCs, 4 E HS, 4 leaders, a -2 & 3 -1s, supported by 2 each MMG...
Top