Search results

This is an open invitation to anyone looking for a CM PBEM game. Even if this post is months old, feel free to email me if you're looking for a game. I'm willing to play pretty much anything, which includes: CMBO, CMBB, CMAK Scenarios or QBs Any Size Any nationality Playtest scenarios...

At the risk of highjacking the thread (again), I thought the game did a lot of things completely wrong. I didn't like the audio, I didn't like the card placement it enforced, I didn't like the card restriction rules, I thought the game was sluggish, even for a top end machine, etc. (But...

Actually, that's pretty much what I was getting at. The card game is great (if you're into that sort of thing: I was/am). The first few computer versions were utter crap, and really didn't reproduce the "essence" of the game. I haven't played Magic Online, so I can't really comment, but it...

I think that's a bit of a stretch. I think most folks know that you can't judge a book based on a movie (and vice versa), so I doubt they'd compare a board game to a computer game. Here are a few examples: Magic: card vs computer Fight Club: Movie vs game (movie great, game sucked)...

At the risk of starting a flame war, what difference does it make if they screw it up? It's not as it will have impact on ASL itself, nor will it prevent another company from trying to build a computer version of ASL. Nat

I have several Paradox titles, and I thought they were quite good. I didn't see any glaring problems with the faithfulness of the product to historical events and context, and I certainly didn't see software bugs to the extent that some have reported. So I'm going to be guardedly optimistic...

My first scenario was The Guards Counterattack against Adrian Earle. I was commading the German force, and got properly stomped. Learned my first tactical lesson of ASL: try to keep units together in small groups, but in different hexes, to form FGs and take out the enemy. I was pretty much...

Quebec City, eh? A very good friend of mine lives there, and I visit a few times a year. What if I could sneak out for an afternoon? Nat

Chapters A-D give me the hardest time... In all seriousness though, bypass give me a hard time, as does the blind hex system. But like a few have mentioned, it's not any specific rule, it's the volume of rules. I guess that comes with a lot of playing. Nat

I'm still very much in the learning phase, so I prefer someone with patience, and who can teach me the rules as well as strategy & tactics. I also refuse to play arseholes. Fortunately, I've yet to play against one. Other than that, I don't care who I play. Nat

Tom Repetti and Sam Belcher: Games against them must be a riot! Nat

I don't have the numbers in my head, but I like the dense urban maps. The RB maps come to mind. Mark: Have you tried designing your own maps? I know you've worked on a lot of scenarios, how much extra work would it be to make your own maps? Nat

I think you're missing the point. The MMP guys didn't start the business to make money, they started the business to keep wargaming alive. With that goal in mind, the ROI, or the fact that the company revenues aren't enough to support the entire staff are irrelevant. I think MMP is wildly...

We're now comparing counter upgrades to the discovery of penicillin?! :) I think it doesn't make a difference one way or the other. More stuff is always good, especially for those that have all of the current ASL stuff. For those who don't think new counters are important, they can add it...

Why does it have to be a scenario published in 2001 or earlier (I don't have Journal 4)? Thanks, Nat

I'm a killer stack defender. I think the killer stack is a simpler defense than the in-depth defense, for two reasons. First, all you need to find is a good line to set your defense, and you're there. Sometimes the scenario will give you this line of cover in your starting position, and...

See, this is one thing I really hate about ASL. There's so much material out there, how is one supposed to make up a Christmas list? :) Nat

One question: by adding a new board to the system, is it an implicit assumption that scenarios that make use of that board will be in the Journal as well? I think it's a good idea either way, both for newbies and veterans. For newbies, it's an extra bit of material they can get if they want...

To the contrary, my friend, it does take skill. My first few games were against a vastly superior player, and while I had the elite units, I got *creamed* by half his force, which was composed of 2nd line and conscript troops. Elite units won't save you if you really suck. A minimum amount...

That's not really surprising. Low quality units aren't interesting to play. Because low quality units tend to break far more often, I feel like I'm watching the game, rather than playing it. I prefer scenarios where elites are facing elites, or at least, 1st line vs 1st line. Makes things far...