Hi-
I should also mention that like the scenario Bartodo, there are many ways to both defend and to attack, does the German player have pickets up front to try and slow the Americans down and deny concealment? Do the Americans attack on a wide front? Do they attack on one flank? do they attack on both flanks? Unlike some designers that design scenarios to micro manage your attack and defense, Andy made his scenarios more open ended and gave the players the option on how they will approach each scenario in Hatten. This of course requires a ton of playtesting, beyond a year because of the more far ranging options the attacker and defender have. I really wish other designers would take note of more open ended scenarios instead of cranking out a scenario pack of forgettable scenarios per a year.