PDA

View Full Version : Scenario Review section

Mad Cow
12 May 03, 18:55
I was wondering if it is possible for Warfare HQ to add a scenario review section for TOAW. There are so many scenario out there and some are great, others are not worth the time or effort to PBEM them.
Mantis
12 May 03, 19:11
This idea has been kicked around, and we're not quite done with it yet. There are alot of things on the go at the moment, but I'll be revisiting this idea again shortly. There's a new section about to go up, and some ladder changes. Between that and the new tourney work, I'm already working full time, so something has to be put on the back burner for a bit.

It is a great idea tho, and thanx for bringing it up again! We'll get something going on that front eventually!
Mad Cow
12 May 03, 19:29
Cool, thanks for the reply and good luck.
Mantis
12 May 03, 20:11
You bet!

(Do you promise to do a bunch of reviews if I get this up sooner or later? :D)
Siberian HEAT
12 May 03, 20:44
Originally posted by Mantis
You bet!

(...if I get this up sooner or later? :D)

Oh man...talk about a setup!

:laugh:
Mantis
12 May 03, 20:49
Uggghhhhh.... I've been too busy today, I didn't even *notice* that one! :D
JAMiAM
12 May 03, 21:47
Damn...I'm getting slow...:bored:
Mad Cow
12 May 03, 22:25
Originally posted by Mantis
You bet!

(Do you promise to do a bunch of reviews if I get this up sooner or later? :D)


depends, if it something like the Combat Mission scenario depot where you rate different categories and write a brief comment section, then I will review every scenario I have played.

If you are talking about a film type review, then I won't have to time to do very many. I am out of school for the summer but I am starting a swing shift job at a gypsum plant/quarry, so my time will be strained, to say the least...
LanceRunolfsson
13 May 03, 02:48
aybe a neat way to do this is as said above a short questioner

# Turns

Turn speed in hours or minutes (how long it takes you to do a turn)

Perceived balance (with a recommendation that only guys playing mirrors rate this or that their be a box to check if a mirror was played and that those responses be more heavily weighted.)

Entertainment value

Impact of events (lets face it if you get your reinforcements early and he gets his late that can really scew results.)

Then make the aggregate results available in quick view with a statement of sample size for in depth give the complete view of all questioners filled out including handles of the respondents